Subnational Insolvency : Cross-Country Experiences and Lessons

Subnational insolvency is a reoccurring event in development, as demonstrated by historical and modern episodes of subnational defaults in both developed and developing countries. Insolvency procedures become more important as countries decentraliz...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Liu, Lili, Waibel, Michael
Format: Policy Research Working Paper
Language:English
Published: 2012
Subjects:
APR
Online Access:http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2008/01/8972981/subnational-insolvency-cross-country-experiences-lessons
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/6384
id okr-10986-6384
recordtype oai_dc
repository_type Digital Repository
institution_category Foreign Institution
institution Digital Repositories
building World Bank Open Knowledge Repository
collection World Bank
language English
topic ABSOLUTE PRIORITY RULE
ALLOCATION OF CREDIT
APR
ARREARS
ASSETS
ASSETS FOR DISTRIBUTION
ASSETS IN BANKRUPTCY
BAILOUT
BAILOUTS
BANK FINANCING
BANK LOANS
BANKING SYSTEM
BANKRUPT
BANKRUPTCY
BANKRUPTCY CODE
BANKRUPTCY EXEMPTION
BANKRUPTCY PREVENTION
BANKRUPTCY PROCEDURES
BANKRUPTCY PROCEEDINGS
BANKRUPTCY PROTECTION
BARGAINING POWER
BOND MARKET
BOND MARKETS
BONDHOLDERS
BORROWER
BUDGET CONSTRAINT
BUDGET CONSTRAINTS
CAPITAL MARKET
CAPITAL MARKETS
CHAPTER 13
CLAIM
COLLECTIVE ACTION
COLLECTIVE ACTION PROBLEM
COMMENCEMENT OF BANKRUPTCY
CONTINGENT LIABILITIES
CONTRACT LAWS
CONTRACTUAL RIGHTS
CONTRACTUAL RIGHTS OF CREDITORS
CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY
CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY LAW
CORPORATE INSOLVENCY
CORPORATE INSOLVENCY LAW
COURT JUDGMENT
COURT ORDER
COURT SYSTEM
CREDIT MARKETS
CREDITOR
CREDITOR ACTION
CREDITOR CLAIMS
CREDITOR RIGHTS
CREDITORS
CREDITS
CREDITWORTHINESS
DEBT
DEBT ADJUSTMENT
DEBT ADJUSTMENT LAW
DEBT ADJUSTMENT PLAN
DEBT ADJUSTMENT PROCESS
DEBT ADJUSTMENTS
DEBT COLLECTION
DEBT CRISES
DEBT CRISIS
DEBT FINANCING
DEBT MARKET
DEBT MARKETS
DEBT OBLIGATIONS
DEBT PAYMENT
DEBT PAYMENTS
DEBT RESTRUCTURING
DEBT RESTRUCTURING MECHANISM
DEBT SERVICE
DEBT SERVICES
DEBTOR
DEBTOR-CREDITOR RELATIONSHIP
DEBTORS
DEFAULTS
DEFICIT GRANT
DEPENDENT
DISSOLUTION
DOMESTIC CREDITORS
EMERGENCY LOAN
ESTATE
EVENT OF DEFAULT
FEDERAL BANKRUPTCY
FINANCIAL CRISIS
FINANCIAL DISTRESS
FINANCIAL INDICATORS
FINANCIAL INSTITUTION
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FINANCIAL POSITION
FINANCIAL REHABILITATION
FINANCIAL RELIEF
FINANCIAL REPORTING
FINANCIAL RESOURCES
FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
FINANCIAL STABILITY
FINANCIAL SYSTEM
FINANCIAL TROUBLES
FISCAL DEFICIT
FISCAL DEFICITS
FISCAL DISTRESS
FISCAL REFORMS
FORECLOSURE
FOREIGN CREDITORS
FRAMEWORK FOR INSOLVENCY
GOVERNMENT BANKRUPTCY
GOVERNMENT GUARANTEE
GOVERNMENT GUARANTEES
GROUP OF CREDITORS
HARD BUDGET
INDEBTED
INDIVIDUAL CREDITOR
INDIVIDUAL CREDITORS
INSOLVENCY
INSOLVENCY FRAMEWORK
INSOLVENCY LAW
INSOLVENCY LEGISLATION
INSOLVENCY MECHANISM
INSOLVENCY MECHANISMS
INSOLVENCY PROCEDURE
INSOLVENCY PROCEDURES
INSOLVENCY PROCESS
INSOLVENCY REGULATION
INSOLVENCY STATUTE
INSOLVENCY SYSTEM
INSOLVENCY SYSTEMS
INSOLVENT
INSTITUTIONAL REFORMS
INSURANCE
INTEREST OF CREDITORS
INTEREST RATES
INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL
INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW
INTRODUCTION OF INSOLVENCY
IRRESPONSIBLE BORROWING
JUDGE
JUDGMENT
JUDGMENTS
JUDICIAL PROCEDURES
JUDICIAL SYSTEM
JUDICIARY
JURISDICTION
LACK OF TRANSPARENCY
LEGAL FRAMEWORK
LEGAL PROCEDURE
LEGAL PROCEDURES
LEGAL REMEDIES
LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK
LENDER
LENDERS
LEVERAGE
LIQUIDATION
LIQUIDITY
LITERATURE ON BANKRUPTCY
LOCAL DEBT
LOCAL GOVERNMENT DEBT
MAJORITY OF CREDITORS
MARKET VALUE
MECHANISMS FOR INSOLVENCY
MISMANAGEMENT
MORTGAGES
MUNICIPAL ASSETS
MUNICIPAL BANKRUPTCY
MUNICIPAL BANKRUPTCY CASES
MUNICIPAL BORROWING
MUNICIPAL DEBT
MUNICIPAL DEBT ADJUSTMENT
MUNICIPAL DEFAULT
MUNICIPAL DEFAULTS
MUNICIPAL INSOLVENCY
NATIONAL DEBT
NEGOTIATION
NEGOTIATIONS
OUTSIDE BANKRUPTCY
PARTIAL IMMUNITY
POSSESSION
POSSESSION FINANCING
POTENTIAL LIABILITIES
POWER OF CREDITORS
PRIORITY OF CREDITOR
PRIVATE CREDITORS
PRIVATE INVESTMENTS
PRIVATE LAW
REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
REGULATORY REFORMS
RELIEF FROM CREDITORS
REMEDY
REORGANIZATION
REORGANIZATION PROCEDURES
REPAYMENT
REPAYMENT OF CREDITORS
REPAYMENT OF DEBT
RESTRUCTURING PLAN
RESTRUCTURING PROCESS
RISK OF DEBT
ROLE OF COURTS
SALARY
SATISFACTION OF CREDITOR
SATISFACTION OF CREDITORS
SECURED DEBT
SHORT-TERM DEBTS
SIMILARLY SITUATED CREDITORS
SINGLE DEBT
SOVEREIGN DEBT
STATE DEBT
TRUSTEE
UNSECURED CREDITORS
UNSECURED DEBT
WAGES
WORKOUT
WORKOUTS
spellingShingle ABSOLUTE PRIORITY RULE
ALLOCATION OF CREDIT
APR
ARREARS
ASSETS
ASSETS FOR DISTRIBUTION
ASSETS IN BANKRUPTCY
BAILOUT
BAILOUTS
BANK FINANCING
BANK LOANS
BANKING SYSTEM
BANKRUPT
BANKRUPTCY
BANKRUPTCY CODE
BANKRUPTCY EXEMPTION
BANKRUPTCY PREVENTION
BANKRUPTCY PROCEDURES
BANKRUPTCY PROCEEDINGS
BANKRUPTCY PROTECTION
BARGAINING POWER
BOND MARKET
BOND MARKETS
BONDHOLDERS
BORROWER
BUDGET CONSTRAINT
BUDGET CONSTRAINTS
CAPITAL MARKET
CAPITAL MARKETS
CHAPTER 13
CLAIM
COLLECTIVE ACTION
COLLECTIVE ACTION PROBLEM
COMMENCEMENT OF BANKRUPTCY
CONTINGENT LIABILITIES
CONTRACT LAWS
CONTRACTUAL RIGHTS
CONTRACTUAL RIGHTS OF CREDITORS
CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY
CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY LAW
CORPORATE INSOLVENCY
CORPORATE INSOLVENCY LAW
COURT JUDGMENT
COURT ORDER
COURT SYSTEM
CREDIT MARKETS
CREDITOR
CREDITOR ACTION
CREDITOR CLAIMS
CREDITOR RIGHTS
CREDITORS
CREDITS
CREDITWORTHINESS
DEBT
DEBT ADJUSTMENT
DEBT ADJUSTMENT LAW
DEBT ADJUSTMENT PLAN
DEBT ADJUSTMENT PROCESS
DEBT ADJUSTMENTS
DEBT COLLECTION
DEBT CRISES
DEBT CRISIS
DEBT FINANCING
DEBT MARKET
DEBT MARKETS
DEBT OBLIGATIONS
DEBT PAYMENT
DEBT PAYMENTS
DEBT RESTRUCTURING
DEBT RESTRUCTURING MECHANISM
DEBT SERVICE
DEBT SERVICES
DEBTOR
DEBTOR-CREDITOR RELATIONSHIP
DEBTORS
DEFAULTS
DEFICIT GRANT
DEPENDENT
DISSOLUTION
DOMESTIC CREDITORS
EMERGENCY LOAN
ESTATE
EVENT OF DEFAULT
FEDERAL BANKRUPTCY
FINANCIAL CRISIS
FINANCIAL DISTRESS
FINANCIAL INDICATORS
FINANCIAL INSTITUTION
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FINANCIAL POSITION
FINANCIAL REHABILITATION
FINANCIAL RELIEF
FINANCIAL REPORTING
FINANCIAL RESOURCES
FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
FINANCIAL STABILITY
FINANCIAL SYSTEM
FINANCIAL TROUBLES
FISCAL DEFICIT
FISCAL DEFICITS
FISCAL DISTRESS
FISCAL REFORMS
FORECLOSURE
FOREIGN CREDITORS
FRAMEWORK FOR INSOLVENCY
GOVERNMENT BANKRUPTCY
GOVERNMENT GUARANTEE
GOVERNMENT GUARANTEES
GROUP OF CREDITORS
HARD BUDGET
INDEBTED
INDIVIDUAL CREDITOR
INDIVIDUAL CREDITORS
INSOLVENCY
INSOLVENCY FRAMEWORK
INSOLVENCY LAW
INSOLVENCY LEGISLATION
INSOLVENCY MECHANISM
INSOLVENCY MECHANISMS
INSOLVENCY PROCEDURE
INSOLVENCY PROCEDURES
INSOLVENCY PROCESS
INSOLVENCY REGULATION
INSOLVENCY STATUTE
INSOLVENCY SYSTEM
INSOLVENCY SYSTEMS
INSOLVENT
INSTITUTIONAL REFORMS
INSURANCE
INTEREST OF CREDITORS
INTEREST RATES
INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL
INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW
INTRODUCTION OF INSOLVENCY
IRRESPONSIBLE BORROWING
JUDGE
JUDGMENT
JUDGMENTS
JUDICIAL PROCEDURES
JUDICIAL SYSTEM
JUDICIARY
JURISDICTION
LACK OF TRANSPARENCY
LEGAL FRAMEWORK
LEGAL PROCEDURE
LEGAL PROCEDURES
LEGAL REMEDIES
LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK
LENDER
LENDERS
LEVERAGE
LIQUIDATION
LIQUIDITY
LITERATURE ON BANKRUPTCY
LOCAL DEBT
LOCAL GOVERNMENT DEBT
MAJORITY OF CREDITORS
MARKET VALUE
MECHANISMS FOR INSOLVENCY
MISMANAGEMENT
MORTGAGES
MUNICIPAL ASSETS
MUNICIPAL BANKRUPTCY
MUNICIPAL BANKRUPTCY CASES
MUNICIPAL BORROWING
MUNICIPAL DEBT
MUNICIPAL DEBT ADJUSTMENT
MUNICIPAL DEFAULT
MUNICIPAL DEFAULTS
MUNICIPAL INSOLVENCY
NATIONAL DEBT
NEGOTIATION
NEGOTIATIONS
OUTSIDE BANKRUPTCY
PARTIAL IMMUNITY
POSSESSION
POSSESSION FINANCING
POTENTIAL LIABILITIES
POWER OF CREDITORS
PRIORITY OF CREDITOR
PRIVATE CREDITORS
PRIVATE INVESTMENTS
PRIVATE LAW
REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
REGULATORY REFORMS
RELIEF FROM CREDITORS
REMEDY
REORGANIZATION
REORGANIZATION PROCEDURES
REPAYMENT
REPAYMENT OF CREDITORS
REPAYMENT OF DEBT
RESTRUCTURING PLAN
RESTRUCTURING PROCESS
RISK OF DEBT
ROLE OF COURTS
SALARY
SATISFACTION OF CREDITOR
SATISFACTION OF CREDITORS
SECURED DEBT
SHORT-TERM DEBTS
SIMILARLY SITUATED CREDITORS
SINGLE DEBT
SOVEREIGN DEBT
STATE DEBT
TRUSTEE
UNSECURED CREDITORS
UNSECURED DEBT
WAGES
WORKOUT
WORKOUTS
Liu, Lili
Waibel, Michael
Subnational Insolvency : Cross-Country Experiences and Lessons
relation Policy Research Working Paper; No. 4496
description Subnational insolvency is a reoccurring event in development, as demonstrated by historical and modern episodes of subnational defaults in both developed and developing countries. Insolvency procedures become more important as countries decentralize expenditure, taxation, and borrowing, and broaden subnational credit markets. As the first cross-country survey of procedures to resolve subnational financial distress, this paper has particular relevance for decentralizing countries. The authors explain central features and variations of subnational insolvency mechanisms across countries. They identify judicial, administrative, and hybrid procedures, and show how entry point and political factors drive their design. Like private insolvency law, subnational insolvency procedures predictably allocate default risk, while providing breathing space for orderly debt restructuring and fiscal adjustment. Policymakers' desire to mitigate the tension between creditor rights and the need to maintain essential public services, to strengthen ex ante fiscal rules, and to harden subnational budget constraints are motivations specific to the public sector.
format Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper
author Liu, Lili
Waibel, Michael
author_facet Liu, Lili
Waibel, Michael
author_sort Liu, Lili
title Subnational Insolvency : Cross-Country Experiences and Lessons
title_short Subnational Insolvency : Cross-Country Experiences and Lessons
title_full Subnational Insolvency : Cross-Country Experiences and Lessons
title_fullStr Subnational Insolvency : Cross-Country Experiences and Lessons
title_full_unstemmed Subnational Insolvency : Cross-Country Experiences and Lessons
title_sort subnational insolvency : cross-country experiences and lessons
publishDate 2012
url http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2008/01/8972981/subnational-insolvency-cross-country-experiences-lessons
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/6384
_version_ 1764400261568135168
spelling okr-10986-63842021-04-23T14:02:31Z Subnational Insolvency : Cross-Country Experiences and Lessons Liu, Lili Waibel, Michael ABSOLUTE PRIORITY RULE ALLOCATION OF CREDIT APR ARREARS ASSETS ASSETS FOR DISTRIBUTION ASSETS IN BANKRUPTCY BAILOUT BAILOUTS BANK FINANCING BANK LOANS BANKING SYSTEM BANKRUPT BANKRUPTCY BANKRUPTCY CODE BANKRUPTCY EXEMPTION BANKRUPTCY PREVENTION BANKRUPTCY PROCEDURES BANKRUPTCY PROCEEDINGS BANKRUPTCY PROTECTION BARGAINING POWER BOND MARKET BOND MARKETS BONDHOLDERS BORROWER BUDGET CONSTRAINT BUDGET CONSTRAINTS CAPITAL MARKET CAPITAL MARKETS CHAPTER 13 CLAIM COLLECTIVE ACTION COLLECTIVE ACTION PROBLEM COMMENCEMENT OF BANKRUPTCY CONTINGENT LIABILITIES CONTRACT LAWS CONTRACTUAL RIGHTS CONTRACTUAL RIGHTS OF CREDITORS CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY LAW CORPORATE INSOLVENCY CORPORATE INSOLVENCY LAW COURT JUDGMENT COURT ORDER COURT SYSTEM CREDIT MARKETS CREDITOR CREDITOR ACTION CREDITOR CLAIMS CREDITOR RIGHTS CREDITORS CREDITS CREDITWORTHINESS DEBT DEBT ADJUSTMENT DEBT ADJUSTMENT LAW DEBT ADJUSTMENT PLAN DEBT ADJUSTMENT PROCESS DEBT ADJUSTMENTS DEBT COLLECTION DEBT CRISES DEBT CRISIS DEBT FINANCING DEBT MARKET DEBT MARKETS DEBT OBLIGATIONS DEBT PAYMENT DEBT PAYMENTS DEBT RESTRUCTURING DEBT RESTRUCTURING MECHANISM DEBT SERVICE DEBT SERVICES DEBTOR DEBTOR-CREDITOR RELATIONSHIP DEBTORS DEFAULTS DEFICIT GRANT DEPENDENT DISSOLUTION DOMESTIC CREDITORS EMERGENCY LOAN ESTATE EVENT OF DEFAULT FEDERAL BANKRUPTCY FINANCIAL CRISIS FINANCIAL DISTRESS FINANCIAL INDICATORS FINANCIAL INSTITUTION FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT FINANCIAL MARKETS FINANCIAL POSITION FINANCIAL REHABILITATION FINANCIAL RELIEF FINANCIAL REPORTING FINANCIAL RESOURCES FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY FINANCIAL STABILITY FINANCIAL SYSTEM FINANCIAL TROUBLES FISCAL DEFICIT FISCAL DEFICITS FISCAL DISTRESS FISCAL REFORMS FORECLOSURE FOREIGN CREDITORS FRAMEWORK FOR INSOLVENCY GOVERNMENT BANKRUPTCY GOVERNMENT GUARANTEE GOVERNMENT GUARANTEES GROUP OF CREDITORS HARD BUDGET INDEBTED INDIVIDUAL CREDITOR INDIVIDUAL CREDITORS INSOLVENCY INSOLVENCY FRAMEWORK INSOLVENCY LAW INSOLVENCY LEGISLATION INSOLVENCY MECHANISM INSOLVENCY MECHANISMS INSOLVENCY PROCEDURE INSOLVENCY PROCEDURES INSOLVENCY PROCESS INSOLVENCY REGULATION INSOLVENCY STATUTE INSOLVENCY SYSTEM INSOLVENCY SYSTEMS INSOLVENT INSTITUTIONAL REFORMS INSURANCE INTEREST OF CREDITORS INTEREST RATES INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW INTRODUCTION OF INSOLVENCY IRRESPONSIBLE BORROWING JUDGE JUDGMENT JUDGMENTS JUDICIAL PROCEDURES JUDICIAL SYSTEM JUDICIARY JURISDICTION LACK OF TRANSPARENCY LEGAL FRAMEWORK LEGAL PROCEDURE LEGAL PROCEDURES LEGAL REMEDIES LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK LENDER LENDERS LEVERAGE LIQUIDATION LIQUIDITY LITERATURE ON BANKRUPTCY LOCAL DEBT LOCAL GOVERNMENT DEBT MAJORITY OF CREDITORS MARKET VALUE MECHANISMS FOR INSOLVENCY MISMANAGEMENT MORTGAGES MUNICIPAL ASSETS MUNICIPAL BANKRUPTCY MUNICIPAL BANKRUPTCY CASES MUNICIPAL BORROWING MUNICIPAL DEBT MUNICIPAL DEBT ADJUSTMENT MUNICIPAL DEFAULT MUNICIPAL DEFAULTS MUNICIPAL INSOLVENCY NATIONAL DEBT NEGOTIATION NEGOTIATIONS OUTSIDE BANKRUPTCY PARTIAL IMMUNITY POSSESSION POSSESSION FINANCING POTENTIAL LIABILITIES POWER OF CREDITORS PRIORITY OF CREDITOR PRIVATE CREDITORS PRIVATE INVESTMENTS PRIVATE LAW REGULATORY FRAMEWORK REGULATORY REFORMS RELIEF FROM CREDITORS REMEDY REORGANIZATION REORGANIZATION PROCEDURES REPAYMENT REPAYMENT OF CREDITORS REPAYMENT OF DEBT RESTRUCTURING PLAN RESTRUCTURING PROCESS RISK OF DEBT ROLE OF COURTS SALARY SATISFACTION OF CREDITOR SATISFACTION OF CREDITORS SECURED DEBT SHORT-TERM DEBTS SIMILARLY SITUATED CREDITORS SINGLE DEBT SOVEREIGN DEBT STATE DEBT TRUSTEE UNSECURED CREDITORS UNSECURED DEBT WAGES WORKOUT WORKOUTS Subnational insolvency is a reoccurring event in development, as demonstrated by historical and modern episodes of subnational defaults in both developed and developing countries. Insolvency procedures become more important as countries decentralize expenditure, taxation, and borrowing, and broaden subnational credit markets. As the first cross-country survey of procedures to resolve subnational financial distress, this paper has particular relevance for decentralizing countries. The authors explain central features and variations of subnational insolvency mechanisms across countries. They identify judicial, administrative, and hybrid procedures, and show how entry point and political factors drive their design. Like private insolvency law, subnational insolvency procedures predictably allocate default risk, while providing breathing space for orderly debt restructuring and fiscal adjustment. Policymakers' desire to mitigate the tension between creditor rights and the need to maintain essential public services, to strengthen ex ante fiscal rules, and to harden subnational budget constraints are motivations specific to the public sector. 2012-05-24T20:01:22Z 2012-05-24T20:01:22Z 2008-01 http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2008/01/8972981/subnational-insolvency-cross-country-experiences-lessons World Bank, Washington, DC http://hdl.handle.net/10986/6384 English Policy Research Working Paper; No. 4496 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper Publications & Research