Trade Remedies and Non-Market Economies : Economic Implications of the First US Countervailing Duty Case on China

In 2007, the United States Department of Commerce altered a 23-year old policy of not applying the countervailing duty law to non-market economies, and initiated eight countervailing and antidumping duty investigations on Chinese imports. The chang...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Zhao, Longyue, Wang, Yan
Format: Policy Research Working Paper
Language:English
Published: Washington, DC: World Bank 2012
Subjects:
GDP
ITC
TAX
WTO
Online Access:http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2008/03/13896462/trade-remedies-non-market-economies-economic-implications-first-countervailing-duty-case-china
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/6319
id okr-10986-6319
recordtype oai_dc
repository_type Digital Repository
institution_category Foreign Institution
institution Digital Repositories
building World Bank Open Knowledge Repository
collection World Bank
language English
topic ACTIONABLE SUBSIDIES
AD VALOREM
ADVERSE EFFECTS
ADVERSE IMPACT
ADVERSE TRADE EFFECTS
AFFIRMATIVE INJURY DETERMINATION
AGREEMENT ON SUBSIDIES
AGRICULTURE
ANTI-DUMPING ACTIONS
ANTIDUMPING DUTY
ANTIDUMPING LAWS
ANTIDUMPING MEASURES
APPELLATE BODY
APPELLATE BODY REPORT
BANK LENDING
BANK LOANS
BANKRUPTCY
BARRIER
BARTER
BENCHMARK
BENCHMARKING
BENCHMARKS
BILATERAL TRADE
CAPACITY BUILDING
CENTRAL PLANNING
CENTRALLY PLANNED ECONOMIES
CENTRALLY PLANNED ECONOMY
COMMERCE
COMMERCIAL BANK
COMMERCIAL BANKS
COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGE
COMPLAINING COUNTRY
CONSUMER SURPLUS
CONSUMERS
CONTRACTING PARTIES
COUNTERVAILING DUTIES
COUNTERVAILING DUTY INVESTIGATION
COUNTERVAILING MEASURES
CURRENCY
CURRENCY EXCHANGE RATES
CUSTOMS
DARK AMBER SUBSIDIES
DEBT
DEBTS
DEPRECIATION OF ASSETS
DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
DEVELOPING COUNTRY
DEVELOPMENT POLICIES
DIRECT TRANSFER
DIRECT TRANSFERS
DISPUTE SETTLEMENT
DISPUTE SETTLEMENT BODY
DISPUTE SETTLEMENT MECHANISM
DISPUTE SETTLEMENT PROCEDURES
DOMESTIC INDUSTRIES
DOMESTIC PRICES
DUMPED IMPORTS
DUMPING
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY
ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS
ECONOMIC RELATIONS
ECONOMIC SYSTEMS
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
EQUITY INFUSION
EUROPEAN UNION
EXCHANGE RATE
EXCHANGE RATE SYSTEM
EXCHANGE RATES
EXPANSION OF TRADE
EXPORT PRICE
EXPORT SUBSIDIES
EXPORT SUBSIDY
EXPORTING COUNTRIES
EXPORTING COUNTRY
EXPORTS
FACTORS OF PRODUCTION
FAIR
FAIR MARKET VALUE
FAIR TRADE
FAIR VALUE
FINANCIAL CONTRIBUTION
FOREIGN BANK
FOREIGN BANKS
FOREIGN COUNTRIES
FOREIGN COUNTRY
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT
FOREIGN GOVERNMENT
FOREIGN INVESTMENT
FOREIGN PURCHASERS
FOREIGN TRADE
FREE TRADE
GDP
GLOBAL EXPORT
GOVERNANCE INDICATORS
GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION
GOVERNMENT INVOLVEMENT
GOVERNMENT SUBSIDIES
GRANTING AUTHORITY
HOME MARKET
HUMAN CAPITAL
IMPORT SUBSTITUTION
IMPORT SUBSTITUTION SUBSIDIES
IMPORTED GOODS
IMPORTING COUNTRIES
IMPORTING COUNTRY
INCOME
INCOME GROUP
INCOME LEVELS
INCOME TAX
INDUSTRIAL COUNTRIES
INEFFICIENCY
INFLATION
INPUT PRICES
INSURANCE
INTEREST RATE
INTEREST RATES
INTERNAL MARKET
INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNTING STANDARDS
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INTERNATIONAL LAW
INTERNATIONAL TRADE
INVESTIGATING AUTHORITIES
ITC
JOINT VENTURES
JUDICIAL REVIEW
JURISDICTION
LIBERALIZATION
LOCAL BANK
MARKET DISTORTIONS
MARKET ECONOMIES
MARKET ECONOMY
MARKET ECONOMY COUNTRIES
MARKET FAILURES
MARKET FORCES
MARKET ORIENTATION
MARKET PRICES
MARKET REFORMS
MARKET RISK
MARKET SHARE
MARKET VALUE
MATERIAL INJURY
MERCHANDISE
MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES
MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRY
MONOPOLIES
MONOPOLY
NATIONAL ECONOMY
NATIONAL INCOME
NON- MARKET ECONOMY
NON-ACTIONABLE SUBSIDIES
NON-MARKET ECONOMY
OUTPUT
POLICY RESEARCH
POLITICAL CONSIDERATIONS
POLITICAL REASONS
POLITICAL STABILITY
PREFERENTIAL LOAN
PRELIMINARY DETERMINATION
PRICE COMPARABILITY
PRICE CONTROLS
PRICE SUBSIDIES
PRICE SUPPORT
PRICE TAKERS
PRODUCTION COSTS
PROHIBITED SUBSIDIES
PROHIBITED SUBSIDY
PROPERTY LAWS
PUBLIC POLICIES
QUANTITATIVE RESTRICTIONS
RAPID GROWTH
REBATE
REBATES
REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE
SALE
SALES
SAVINGS
SETTLEMENT PROCEDURES
SOCIAL STABILITY
SOCIAL WELFARE
STATE ENTERPRISES
SUBSIDIZATION
SUBSTITUTION
SUPPLY CURVE
SURROGATE MARKET
TAX
TAX BREAKS
TAX CREDITS
TAX LIABILITY
TAX RATE
TAX RATES
TAX TREATMENT
TERMINATION OF PROCEEDINGS
THIRD MARKET
TRADE AGREEMENTS
TRADE BARRIERS
TRADE DISPUTES
TRADE POLICIES
TRADE POLICY
TRADE RELATIONS
TRADE REMEDIES
TRADE REMEDY LAWS
TRADING SYSTEM
TRANSFER OF FUNDS
TRANSITION COUNTRIES
TRANSITION ECONOMIES
TRANSITION ECONOMY
TREASURY
URUGUAY ROUND
WAGE RATES
WORLD ECONOMY
WORLD MARKET
WORLD TRADE
WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION
WORLD TRADING SYSTEM
WTO
spellingShingle ACTIONABLE SUBSIDIES
AD VALOREM
ADVERSE EFFECTS
ADVERSE IMPACT
ADVERSE TRADE EFFECTS
AFFIRMATIVE INJURY DETERMINATION
AGREEMENT ON SUBSIDIES
AGRICULTURE
ANTI-DUMPING ACTIONS
ANTIDUMPING DUTY
ANTIDUMPING LAWS
ANTIDUMPING MEASURES
APPELLATE BODY
APPELLATE BODY REPORT
BANK LENDING
BANK LOANS
BANKRUPTCY
BARRIER
BARTER
BENCHMARK
BENCHMARKING
BENCHMARKS
BILATERAL TRADE
CAPACITY BUILDING
CENTRAL PLANNING
CENTRALLY PLANNED ECONOMIES
CENTRALLY PLANNED ECONOMY
COMMERCE
COMMERCIAL BANK
COMMERCIAL BANKS
COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGE
COMPLAINING COUNTRY
CONSUMER SURPLUS
CONSUMERS
CONTRACTING PARTIES
COUNTERVAILING DUTIES
COUNTERVAILING DUTY INVESTIGATION
COUNTERVAILING MEASURES
CURRENCY
CURRENCY EXCHANGE RATES
CUSTOMS
DARK AMBER SUBSIDIES
DEBT
DEBTS
DEPRECIATION OF ASSETS
DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
DEVELOPING COUNTRY
DEVELOPMENT POLICIES
DIRECT TRANSFER
DIRECT TRANSFERS
DISPUTE SETTLEMENT
DISPUTE SETTLEMENT BODY
DISPUTE SETTLEMENT MECHANISM
DISPUTE SETTLEMENT PROCEDURES
DOMESTIC INDUSTRIES
DOMESTIC PRICES
DUMPED IMPORTS
DUMPING
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY
ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS
ECONOMIC RELATIONS
ECONOMIC SYSTEMS
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
EQUITY INFUSION
EUROPEAN UNION
EXCHANGE RATE
EXCHANGE RATE SYSTEM
EXCHANGE RATES
EXPANSION OF TRADE
EXPORT PRICE
EXPORT SUBSIDIES
EXPORT SUBSIDY
EXPORTING COUNTRIES
EXPORTING COUNTRY
EXPORTS
FACTORS OF PRODUCTION
FAIR
FAIR MARKET VALUE
FAIR TRADE
FAIR VALUE
FINANCIAL CONTRIBUTION
FOREIGN BANK
FOREIGN BANKS
FOREIGN COUNTRIES
FOREIGN COUNTRY
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT
FOREIGN GOVERNMENT
FOREIGN INVESTMENT
FOREIGN PURCHASERS
FOREIGN TRADE
FREE TRADE
GDP
GLOBAL EXPORT
GOVERNANCE INDICATORS
GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION
GOVERNMENT INVOLVEMENT
GOVERNMENT SUBSIDIES
GRANTING AUTHORITY
HOME MARKET
HUMAN CAPITAL
IMPORT SUBSTITUTION
IMPORT SUBSTITUTION SUBSIDIES
IMPORTED GOODS
IMPORTING COUNTRIES
IMPORTING COUNTRY
INCOME
INCOME GROUP
INCOME LEVELS
INCOME TAX
INDUSTRIAL COUNTRIES
INEFFICIENCY
INFLATION
INPUT PRICES
INSURANCE
INTEREST RATE
INTEREST RATES
INTERNAL MARKET
INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNTING STANDARDS
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INTERNATIONAL LAW
INTERNATIONAL TRADE
INVESTIGATING AUTHORITIES
ITC
JOINT VENTURES
JUDICIAL REVIEW
JURISDICTION
LIBERALIZATION
LOCAL BANK
MARKET DISTORTIONS
MARKET ECONOMIES
MARKET ECONOMY
MARKET ECONOMY COUNTRIES
MARKET FAILURES
MARKET FORCES
MARKET ORIENTATION
MARKET PRICES
MARKET REFORMS
MARKET RISK
MARKET SHARE
MARKET VALUE
MATERIAL INJURY
MERCHANDISE
MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES
MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRY
MONOPOLIES
MONOPOLY
NATIONAL ECONOMY
NATIONAL INCOME
NON- MARKET ECONOMY
NON-ACTIONABLE SUBSIDIES
NON-MARKET ECONOMY
OUTPUT
POLICY RESEARCH
POLITICAL CONSIDERATIONS
POLITICAL REASONS
POLITICAL STABILITY
PREFERENTIAL LOAN
PRELIMINARY DETERMINATION
PRICE COMPARABILITY
PRICE CONTROLS
PRICE SUBSIDIES
PRICE SUPPORT
PRICE TAKERS
PRODUCTION COSTS
PROHIBITED SUBSIDIES
PROHIBITED SUBSIDY
PROPERTY LAWS
PUBLIC POLICIES
QUANTITATIVE RESTRICTIONS
RAPID GROWTH
REBATE
REBATES
REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE
SALE
SALES
SAVINGS
SETTLEMENT PROCEDURES
SOCIAL STABILITY
SOCIAL WELFARE
STATE ENTERPRISES
SUBSIDIZATION
SUBSTITUTION
SUPPLY CURVE
SURROGATE MARKET
TAX
TAX BREAKS
TAX CREDITS
TAX LIABILITY
TAX RATE
TAX RATES
TAX TREATMENT
TERMINATION OF PROCEEDINGS
THIRD MARKET
TRADE AGREEMENTS
TRADE BARRIERS
TRADE DISPUTES
TRADE POLICIES
TRADE POLICY
TRADE RELATIONS
TRADE REMEDIES
TRADE REMEDY LAWS
TRADING SYSTEM
TRANSFER OF FUNDS
TRANSITION COUNTRIES
TRANSITION ECONOMIES
TRANSITION ECONOMY
TREASURY
URUGUAY ROUND
WAGE RATES
WORLD ECONOMY
WORLD MARKET
WORLD TRADE
WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION
WORLD TRADING SYSTEM
WTO
Zhao, Longyue
Wang, Yan
Trade Remedies and Non-Market Economies : Economic Implications of the First US Countervailing Duty Case on China
geographic_facet East Asia and Pacific
China
relation Policy Research Working Paper; No. 4560
description In 2007, the United States Department of Commerce altered a 23-year old policy of not applying the countervailing duty law to non-market economies, and initiated eight countervailing and antidumping duty investigations on Chinese imports. The change brings heated debate on trade remedy policies and issues of non-market economies. This study focuses on the first countervailing duty case on imported coated free sheet paper from China and analyzes the implications of this test case for United States-China bilateral trade, and industrial policies in transitioning market economies. The paper also provides a brief review of the economics of subsidies, World Trade Organization rules on subsides and countervailing measures, and United States countervailing duty laws applied to non-market economies. While recently acceded countries should review their domestic development policies from the perspective of economic efficiency and comply with the World Trade Organization rules, it is also important to further clarify the issues of non-market economies under the multilateral trading system, and pay keen attention to the rules negotiations in the current World Trade Organization Doha Development Round.
format Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper
author Zhao, Longyue
Wang, Yan
author_facet Zhao, Longyue
Wang, Yan
author_sort Zhao, Longyue
title Trade Remedies and Non-Market Economies : Economic Implications of the First US Countervailing Duty Case on China
title_short Trade Remedies and Non-Market Economies : Economic Implications of the First US Countervailing Duty Case on China
title_full Trade Remedies and Non-Market Economies : Economic Implications of the First US Countervailing Duty Case on China
title_fullStr Trade Remedies and Non-Market Economies : Economic Implications of the First US Countervailing Duty Case on China
title_full_unstemmed Trade Remedies and Non-Market Economies : Economic Implications of the First US Countervailing Duty Case on China
title_sort trade remedies and non-market economies : economic implications of the first us countervailing duty case on china
publisher Washington, DC: World Bank
publishDate 2012
url http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2008/03/13896462/trade-remedies-non-market-economies-economic-implications-first-countervailing-duty-case-china
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/6319
_version_ 1764399863164829696
spelling okr-10986-63192021-04-23T14:02:30Z Trade Remedies and Non-Market Economies : Economic Implications of the First US Countervailing Duty Case on China Zhao, Longyue Wang, Yan ACTIONABLE SUBSIDIES AD VALOREM ADVERSE EFFECTS ADVERSE IMPACT ADVERSE TRADE EFFECTS AFFIRMATIVE INJURY DETERMINATION AGREEMENT ON SUBSIDIES AGRICULTURE ANTI-DUMPING ACTIONS ANTIDUMPING DUTY ANTIDUMPING LAWS ANTIDUMPING MEASURES APPELLATE BODY APPELLATE BODY REPORT BANK LENDING BANK LOANS BANKRUPTCY BARRIER BARTER BENCHMARK BENCHMARKING BENCHMARKS BILATERAL TRADE CAPACITY BUILDING CENTRAL PLANNING CENTRALLY PLANNED ECONOMIES CENTRALLY PLANNED ECONOMY COMMERCE COMMERCIAL BANK COMMERCIAL BANKS COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGE COMPLAINING COUNTRY CONSUMER SURPLUS CONSUMERS CONTRACTING PARTIES COUNTERVAILING DUTIES COUNTERVAILING DUTY INVESTIGATION COUNTERVAILING MEASURES CURRENCY CURRENCY EXCHANGE RATES CUSTOMS DARK AMBER SUBSIDIES DEBT DEBTS DEPRECIATION OF ASSETS DEVELOPING COUNTRIES DEVELOPING COUNTRY DEVELOPMENT POLICIES DIRECT TRANSFER DIRECT TRANSFERS DISPUTE SETTLEMENT DISPUTE SETTLEMENT BODY DISPUTE SETTLEMENT MECHANISM DISPUTE SETTLEMENT PROCEDURES DOMESTIC INDUSTRIES DOMESTIC PRICES DUMPED IMPORTS DUMPING ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS ECONOMIC RELATIONS ECONOMIC SYSTEMS ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT EQUITY INFUSION EUROPEAN UNION EXCHANGE RATE EXCHANGE RATE SYSTEM EXCHANGE RATES EXPANSION OF TRADE EXPORT PRICE EXPORT SUBSIDIES EXPORT SUBSIDY EXPORTING COUNTRIES EXPORTING COUNTRY EXPORTS FACTORS OF PRODUCTION FAIR FAIR MARKET VALUE FAIR TRADE FAIR VALUE FINANCIAL CONTRIBUTION FOREIGN BANK FOREIGN BANKS FOREIGN COUNTRIES FOREIGN COUNTRY FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT FOREIGN GOVERNMENT FOREIGN INVESTMENT FOREIGN PURCHASERS FOREIGN TRADE FREE TRADE GDP GLOBAL EXPORT GOVERNANCE INDICATORS GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION GOVERNMENT INVOLVEMENT GOVERNMENT SUBSIDIES GRANTING AUTHORITY HOME MARKET HUMAN CAPITAL IMPORT SUBSTITUTION IMPORT SUBSTITUTION SUBSIDIES IMPORTED GOODS IMPORTING COUNTRIES IMPORTING COUNTRY INCOME INCOME GROUP INCOME LEVELS INCOME TAX INDUSTRIAL COUNTRIES INEFFICIENCY INFLATION INPUT PRICES INSURANCE INTEREST RATE INTEREST RATES INTERNAL MARKET INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNTING STANDARDS INTERNATIONAL BANK INTERNATIONAL LAW INTERNATIONAL TRADE INVESTIGATING AUTHORITIES ITC JOINT VENTURES JUDICIAL REVIEW JURISDICTION LIBERALIZATION LOCAL BANK MARKET DISTORTIONS MARKET ECONOMIES MARKET ECONOMY MARKET ECONOMY COUNTRIES MARKET FAILURES MARKET FORCES MARKET ORIENTATION MARKET PRICES MARKET REFORMS MARKET RISK MARKET SHARE MARKET VALUE MATERIAL INJURY MERCHANDISE MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRY MONOPOLIES MONOPOLY NATIONAL ECONOMY NATIONAL INCOME NON- MARKET ECONOMY NON-ACTIONABLE SUBSIDIES NON-MARKET ECONOMY OUTPUT POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL CONSIDERATIONS POLITICAL REASONS POLITICAL STABILITY PREFERENTIAL LOAN PRELIMINARY DETERMINATION PRICE COMPARABILITY PRICE CONTROLS PRICE SUBSIDIES PRICE SUPPORT PRICE TAKERS PRODUCTION COSTS PROHIBITED SUBSIDIES PROHIBITED SUBSIDY PROPERTY LAWS PUBLIC POLICIES QUANTITATIVE RESTRICTIONS RAPID GROWTH REBATE REBATES REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE SALE SALES SAVINGS SETTLEMENT PROCEDURES SOCIAL STABILITY SOCIAL WELFARE STATE ENTERPRISES SUBSIDIZATION SUBSTITUTION SUPPLY CURVE SURROGATE MARKET TAX TAX BREAKS TAX CREDITS TAX LIABILITY TAX RATE TAX RATES TAX TREATMENT TERMINATION OF PROCEEDINGS THIRD MARKET TRADE AGREEMENTS TRADE BARRIERS TRADE DISPUTES TRADE POLICIES TRADE POLICY TRADE RELATIONS TRADE REMEDIES TRADE REMEDY LAWS TRADING SYSTEM TRANSFER OF FUNDS TRANSITION COUNTRIES TRANSITION ECONOMIES TRANSITION ECONOMY TREASURY URUGUAY ROUND WAGE RATES WORLD ECONOMY WORLD MARKET WORLD TRADE WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION WORLD TRADING SYSTEM WTO In 2007, the United States Department of Commerce altered a 23-year old policy of not applying the countervailing duty law to non-market economies, and initiated eight countervailing and antidumping duty investigations on Chinese imports. The change brings heated debate on trade remedy policies and issues of non-market economies. This study focuses on the first countervailing duty case on imported coated free sheet paper from China and analyzes the implications of this test case for United States-China bilateral trade, and industrial policies in transitioning market economies. The paper also provides a brief review of the economics of subsidies, World Trade Organization rules on subsides and countervailing measures, and United States countervailing duty laws applied to non-market economies. While recently acceded countries should review their domestic development policies from the perspective of economic efficiency and comply with the World Trade Organization rules, it is also important to further clarify the issues of non-market economies under the multilateral trading system, and pay keen attention to the rules negotiations in the current World Trade Organization Doha Development Round. 2012-05-22T19:49:44Z 2012-05-22T19:49:44Z 2008-03 http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2008/03/13896462/trade-remedies-non-market-economies-economic-implications-first-countervailing-duty-case-china http://hdl.handle.net/10986/6319 English Policy Research Working Paper; No. 4560 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank Washington, DC: World Bank Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper Publications & Research East Asia and Pacific China