Did Higher Inequality Impede Growth in Rural China?

This paper estimates the relationship between initial village inequality and subsequent household income growth for a large sample of households in rural China. Using a rich longitudinal survey spanning the years 1987-2002, and controlling for an a...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Benjamin, Dwayne, Brandt, Loren, Giles, John
Format: Policy Research Working Paper
Language:English
Published: 2012
Subjects:
FEE
Online Access:http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/main?menuPK=64187510&pagePK=64193027&piPK=64187937&theSitePK=523679&menuPK=64187510&searchMenuPK=64187283&siteName=WDS&entityID=000158349_20101119093018
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/3964
id okr-10986-3964
recordtype oai_dc
repository_type Digital Repository
institution_category Foreign Institution
institution Digital Repositories
building World Bank Open Knowledge Repository
collection World Bank
language English
topic ACCOUNTABILITY
ADVERSE EFFECTS
ADVERSE IMPACT
AGRICULTURAL SECTOR
ANNUAL GROWTH
ANNUAL GROWTH RATE
ASSET DISTRIBUTION
AVERAGE ANNUAL
AVERAGE GROWTH
AVERAGE INCOMES
BANK
BIAS
BIASES
CAPITAL ACCUMULATION
COLONIAL LAND
CONSUMER PRICE INDEX
CONSUMPTION
CONSUMPTION GROWTH
COOPERATIVES
CORRUPTION
CREDIT
CREDIT MARKET
CREDIT MARKET CONSTRAINTS
CREDIT MARKETS
CROSS-COUNTRY DATA
CROSS-COUNTRY INEQUALITY
DATA SET
DATA SETS
DEPENDENT VARIABLE
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DIFFERENTIAL PATHS
DISTRIBUTION OF LAND
DISTRIBUTIVE POLITICS
DYNAMIC PANEL
ECONOMETRIC ANALYSIS
ECONOMETRIC ISSUES
ECONOMETRICS
ECONOMIC ACTIVITY
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITIES
ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY
ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE
ECONOMIC POLICY
ECONOMIC REFORM
ECONOMIC REFORMS
ECONOMIC REVIEW
ECONOMIC SHOCKS
ECONOMIC STUDIES
EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES
EMPIRICAL ANALYSIS
EMPIRICAL PROBLEMS
EMPIRICAL RESULTS
EMPIRICAL WORK
EMPLOYMENT GUARANTEE SCHEME
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
EMPOWERMENT
ENDOWMENT
ENDOWMENTS
ENTERPRISES
EQUAL OPPORTUNITY
EXCLUSION
EXPENDITURE
EXPENDITURES
EXPLANATORY VARIABLES
FACTOR ENDOWMENTS
FAMILY
FAMILY BUSINESSES
FARM ACTIVITY
FARM EMPLOYMENT
FARM EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
FARM OUTPUT
FEE
FEES
FINANCIAL CRISIS
FINANCIAL SUPPORT
FOREIGN LANGUAGES
FORMAL SOURCES OF CREDITS
FUNCTIONAL FORM
GINI COEFFICIENT
GROUP MEANS
GROWTH EQUATION
GROWTH LITERATURE
GROWTH RATE
GROWTH RATES
GROWTH THEORIES
GROWTH-INEQUALITY RELATIONSHIP
GUARANTEE
GUARANTEE SCHEME
HETEROGENEOUS COMMUNITIES
HIGH INEQUALITY
HIGHER INEQUALITY
HOUSEHOLD
HOUSEHOLD ACCESS
HOUSEHOLD CONSUMPTION
HOUSEHOLD HEAD
HOUSEHOLD INCOME
HOUSEHOLD INCOMES
HOUSEHOLD MEMBERS
HOUSEHOLD PARTICIPATION
HOUSEHOLD PER CAPITA INCOME
HOUSEHOLD SIZE
HOUSEHOLD SURVEY
HOUSEHOLD SURVEYS
HOUSEHOLDS
HUMAN CAPITAL
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
IMPACT OF INEQUALITY
IMPERFECT CREDIT
INCOME DISTRIBUTION
INCOME GROWTH
INCOME INEQUALITY
INCOME VARIABLES
INDICATORS
INEQUALITY
INEQUALITY INDEX
INEQUALITY MEASURE
INEQUALITY MEASURES
INEQUALITY-GROWTH RELATIONSHIP
INSTRUMENTS
INTEREST
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INVESTMENT
JOB OPPORTUNITIES
LABOR MARKETS
LABOUR MARKETS
LAND DISTRIBUTION
LAND REFORM
LINK BETWEEN INEQUALITY AND GROWTH
LOG INCOME
MACROECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS
MACROECONOMICS
MARKET CONSTRAINTS
MARKET DEVELOPMENT
MEAN INCOME
MEAN INCOMES
MEAN LOG DEVIATION
MEASUREMENT ERROR
MEASUREMENT PROBLEMS
MEASURES OF POVERTY
NEGATIVE EFFECT
NEGATIVE GROWTH
NEGATIVE RELATIONSHIP
NET INCOME
NEW MARKETS
0 HYPOTHESIS
OUTCOMES
PEOPLE
PER CAPITA INCOME
PER CAPITA INCOMES
PHYSICAL CAPITAL
POLICIES
POLICY RESEARCH
POLITICAL ECONOMY
POLITICAL ECONOMY MODELS
POLITICAL PARTICIPATION
POOR
POOR HOUSEHOLDS
POST-REFORM
POVERTY
POVERTY DYNAMICS
POVERTY REDUCTION
PRIMARY EDUCATION
PRODUCT
PRODUCTIVITY GROWTH
PROGRAMS
PROPERTY
PROPERTY RIGHTS
PUBLIC ECONOMICS
PUBLIC EDUCATION
PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
PUBLIC EXPENDITURES
PUBLIC FINANCE
PUBLIC GOODS
PUBLIC INVESTMENTS
PUBLIC POLICY
REGRESSION RESULTS
REVENUE
RISING INEQUALITY
RURAL
RURAL CONSUMER
RURAL ECONOMY
RURAL EMPLOYMENT
RURAL HOUSEHOLD
RURAL HOUSEHOLDS
RURAL INEQUALITY
RURAL PUBLIC
SAMPLING
SCHOOL FINANCE
SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCES
SIGNIFICANT EFFECT
SIGNIFICANT NEGATIVE
SMALL BUSINESSES
SOURCES OF INCOME
SURVEY DESIGN
TARGETING
TAXATION
TRANSFERS
VILLAGE
VILLAGE LEADERS
VILLAGES
WAGES
spellingShingle ACCOUNTABILITY
ADVERSE EFFECTS
ADVERSE IMPACT
AGRICULTURAL SECTOR
ANNUAL GROWTH
ANNUAL GROWTH RATE
ASSET DISTRIBUTION
AVERAGE ANNUAL
AVERAGE GROWTH
AVERAGE INCOMES
BANK
BIAS
BIASES
CAPITAL ACCUMULATION
COLONIAL LAND
CONSUMER PRICE INDEX
CONSUMPTION
CONSUMPTION GROWTH
COOPERATIVES
CORRUPTION
CREDIT
CREDIT MARKET
CREDIT MARKET CONSTRAINTS
CREDIT MARKETS
CROSS-COUNTRY DATA
CROSS-COUNTRY INEQUALITY
DATA SET
DATA SETS
DEPENDENT VARIABLE
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DIFFERENTIAL PATHS
DISTRIBUTION OF LAND
DISTRIBUTIVE POLITICS
DYNAMIC PANEL
ECONOMETRIC ANALYSIS
ECONOMETRIC ISSUES
ECONOMETRICS
ECONOMIC ACTIVITY
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITIES
ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY
ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE
ECONOMIC POLICY
ECONOMIC REFORM
ECONOMIC REFORMS
ECONOMIC REVIEW
ECONOMIC SHOCKS
ECONOMIC STUDIES
EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES
EMPIRICAL ANALYSIS
EMPIRICAL PROBLEMS
EMPIRICAL RESULTS
EMPIRICAL WORK
EMPLOYMENT GUARANTEE SCHEME
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
EMPOWERMENT
ENDOWMENT
ENDOWMENTS
ENTERPRISES
EQUAL OPPORTUNITY
EXCLUSION
EXPENDITURE
EXPENDITURES
EXPLANATORY VARIABLES
FACTOR ENDOWMENTS
FAMILY
FAMILY BUSINESSES
FARM ACTIVITY
FARM EMPLOYMENT
FARM EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
FARM OUTPUT
FEE
FEES
FINANCIAL CRISIS
FINANCIAL SUPPORT
FOREIGN LANGUAGES
FORMAL SOURCES OF CREDITS
FUNCTIONAL FORM
GINI COEFFICIENT
GROUP MEANS
GROWTH EQUATION
GROWTH LITERATURE
GROWTH RATE
GROWTH RATES
GROWTH THEORIES
GROWTH-INEQUALITY RELATIONSHIP
GUARANTEE
GUARANTEE SCHEME
HETEROGENEOUS COMMUNITIES
HIGH INEQUALITY
HIGHER INEQUALITY
HOUSEHOLD
HOUSEHOLD ACCESS
HOUSEHOLD CONSUMPTION
HOUSEHOLD HEAD
HOUSEHOLD INCOME
HOUSEHOLD INCOMES
HOUSEHOLD MEMBERS
HOUSEHOLD PARTICIPATION
HOUSEHOLD PER CAPITA INCOME
HOUSEHOLD SIZE
HOUSEHOLD SURVEY
HOUSEHOLD SURVEYS
HOUSEHOLDS
HUMAN CAPITAL
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
IMPACT OF INEQUALITY
IMPERFECT CREDIT
INCOME DISTRIBUTION
INCOME GROWTH
INCOME INEQUALITY
INCOME VARIABLES
INDICATORS
INEQUALITY
INEQUALITY INDEX
INEQUALITY MEASURE
INEQUALITY MEASURES
INEQUALITY-GROWTH RELATIONSHIP
INSTRUMENTS
INTEREST
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INVESTMENT
JOB OPPORTUNITIES
LABOR MARKETS
LABOUR MARKETS
LAND DISTRIBUTION
LAND REFORM
LINK BETWEEN INEQUALITY AND GROWTH
LOG INCOME
MACROECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS
MACROECONOMICS
MARKET CONSTRAINTS
MARKET DEVELOPMENT
MEAN INCOME
MEAN INCOMES
MEAN LOG DEVIATION
MEASUREMENT ERROR
MEASUREMENT PROBLEMS
MEASURES OF POVERTY
NEGATIVE EFFECT
NEGATIVE GROWTH
NEGATIVE RELATIONSHIP
NET INCOME
NEW MARKETS
0 HYPOTHESIS
OUTCOMES
PEOPLE
PER CAPITA INCOME
PER CAPITA INCOMES
PHYSICAL CAPITAL
POLICIES
POLICY RESEARCH
POLITICAL ECONOMY
POLITICAL ECONOMY MODELS
POLITICAL PARTICIPATION
POOR
POOR HOUSEHOLDS
POST-REFORM
POVERTY
POVERTY DYNAMICS
POVERTY REDUCTION
PRIMARY EDUCATION
PRODUCT
PRODUCTIVITY GROWTH
PROGRAMS
PROPERTY
PROPERTY RIGHTS
PUBLIC ECONOMICS
PUBLIC EDUCATION
PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
PUBLIC EXPENDITURES
PUBLIC FINANCE
PUBLIC GOODS
PUBLIC INVESTMENTS
PUBLIC POLICY
REGRESSION RESULTS
REVENUE
RISING INEQUALITY
RURAL
RURAL CONSUMER
RURAL ECONOMY
RURAL EMPLOYMENT
RURAL HOUSEHOLD
RURAL HOUSEHOLDS
RURAL INEQUALITY
RURAL PUBLIC
SAMPLING
SCHOOL FINANCE
SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCES
SIGNIFICANT EFFECT
SIGNIFICANT NEGATIVE
SMALL BUSINESSES
SOURCES OF INCOME
SURVEY DESIGN
TARGETING
TAXATION
TRANSFERS
VILLAGE
VILLAGE LEADERS
VILLAGES
WAGES
Benjamin, Dwayne
Brandt, Loren
Giles, John
Did Higher Inequality Impede Growth in Rural China?
geographic_facet East Asia and Pacific
East Asia and Pacific
East Asia
Asia
China
relation Policy Research working paper ; no. WPS 5483
description This paper estimates the relationship between initial village inequality and subsequent household income growth for a large sample of households in rural China. Using a rich longitudinal survey spanning the years 1987-2002, and controlling for an array of household and village characteristics, the paper finds that households located in higher inequality villages experienced significantly lower income growth through the 1990s. However, local inequality s predictive power and effects are significantly diminished by the end of the sample. The paper exploits several advantages of the household-level data to explore hypotheses that shed light on the channels by which inequality affects growth. Biases due to aggregation and heterogeneity of returns to own-resources, previously suggested as candidate explanations for the relationship, are both ruled out. Instead, the evidence points to unobserved village institutions at the time of economic reforms that were associated with household access to higher income activities as the source of the link between inequality and growth. The empirical analysis addresses a number of pertinent econometric issues including measurement error and attrition, but underscores others that are likely to be intractable for all investigations of the inequality-growth relationship.
format Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper
author Benjamin, Dwayne
Brandt, Loren
Giles, John
author_facet Benjamin, Dwayne
Brandt, Loren
Giles, John
author_sort Benjamin, Dwayne
title Did Higher Inequality Impede Growth in Rural China?
title_short Did Higher Inequality Impede Growth in Rural China?
title_full Did Higher Inequality Impede Growth in Rural China?
title_fullStr Did Higher Inequality Impede Growth in Rural China?
title_full_unstemmed Did Higher Inequality Impede Growth in Rural China?
title_sort did higher inequality impede growth in rural china?
publishDate 2012
url http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/main?menuPK=64187510&pagePK=64193027&piPK=64187937&theSitePK=523679&menuPK=64187510&searchMenuPK=64187283&siteName=WDS&entityID=000158349_20101119093018
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/3964
_version_ 1764389245004283904
spelling okr-10986-39642021-04-23T14:02:14Z Did Higher Inequality Impede Growth in Rural China? Benjamin, Dwayne Brandt, Loren Giles, John ACCOUNTABILITY ADVERSE EFFECTS ADVERSE IMPACT AGRICULTURAL SECTOR ANNUAL GROWTH ANNUAL GROWTH RATE ASSET DISTRIBUTION AVERAGE ANNUAL AVERAGE GROWTH AVERAGE INCOMES BANK BIAS BIASES CAPITAL ACCUMULATION COLONIAL LAND CONSUMER PRICE INDEX CONSUMPTION CONSUMPTION GROWTH COOPERATIVES CORRUPTION CREDIT CREDIT MARKET CREDIT MARKET CONSTRAINTS CREDIT MARKETS CROSS-COUNTRY DATA CROSS-COUNTRY INEQUALITY DATA SET DATA SETS DEPENDENT VARIABLE DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS DIFFERENTIAL PATHS DISTRIBUTION OF LAND DISTRIBUTIVE POLITICS DYNAMIC PANEL ECONOMETRIC ANALYSIS ECONOMETRIC ISSUES ECONOMETRICS ECONOMIC ACTIVITY ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ECONOMIC GROWTH ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITIES ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE ECONOMIC POLICY ECONOMIC REFORM ECONOMIC REFORMS ECONOMIC REVIEW ECONOMIC SHOCKS ECONOMIC STUDIES EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES EMPIRICAL ANALYSIS EMPIRICAL PROBLEMS EMPIRICAL RESULTS EMPIRICAL WORK EMPLOYMENT GUARANTEE SCHEME EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES EMPOWERMENT ENDOWMENT ENDOWMENTS ENTERPRISES EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EXCLUSION EXPENDITURE EXPENDITURES EXPLANATORY VARIABLES FACTOR ENDOWMENTS FAMILY FAMILY BUSINESSES FARM ACTIVITY FARM EMPLOYMENT FARM EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES FARM OUTPUT FEE FEES FINANCIAL CRISIS FINANCIAL SUPPORT FOREIGN LANGUAGES FORMAL SOURCES OF CREDITS FUNCTIONAL FORM GINI COEFFICIENT GROUP MEANS GROWTH EQUATION GROWTH LITERATURE GROWTH RATE GROWTH RATES GROWTH THEORIES GROWTH-INEQUALITY RELATIONSHIP GUARANTEE GUARANTEE SCHEME HETEROGENEOUS COMMUNITIES HIGH INEQUALITY HIGHER INEQUALITY HOUSEHOLD HOUSEHOLD ACCESS HOUSEHOLD CONSUMPTION HOUSEHOLD HEAD HOUSEHOLD INCOME HOUSEHOLD INCOMES HOUSEHOLD MEMBERS HOUSEHOLD PARTICIPATION HOUSEHOLD PER CAPITA INCOME HOUSEHOLD SIZE HOUSEHOLD SURVEY HOUSEHOLD SURVEYS HOUSEHOLDS HUMAN CAPITAL HUMAN DEVELOPMENT IMPACT OF INEQUALITY IMPERFECT CREDIT INCOME DISTRIBUTION INCOME GROWTH INCOME INEQUALITY INCOME VARIABLES INDICATORS INEQUALITY INEQUALITY INDEX INEQUALITY MEASURE INEQUALITY MEASURES INEQUALITY-GROWTH RELATIONSHIP INSTRUMENTS INTEREST INTERNATIONAL BANK INVESTMENT JOB OPPORTUNITIES LABOR MARKETS LABOUR MARKETS LAND DISTRIBUTION LAND REFORM LINK BETWEEN INEQUALITY AND GROWTH LOG INCOME MACROECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS MACROECONOMICS MARKET CONSTRAINTS MARKET DEVELOPMENT MEAN INCOME MEAN INCOMES MEAN LOG DEVIATION MEASUREMENT ERROR MEASUREMENT PROBLEMS MEASURES OF POVERTY NEGATIVE EFFECT NEGATIVE GROWTH NEGATIVE RELATIONSHIP NET INCOME NEW MARKETS 0 HYPOTHESIS OUTCOMES PEOPLE PER CAPITA INCOME PER CAPITA INCOMES PHYSICAL CAPITAL POLICIES POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL ECONOMY POLITICAL ECONOMY MODELS POLITICAL PARTICIPATION POOR POOR HOUSEHOLDS POST-REFORM POVERTY POVERTY DYNAMICS POVERTY REDUCTION PRIMARY EDUCATION PRODUCT PRODUCTIVITY GROWTH PROGRAMS PROPERTY PROPERTY RIGHTS PUBLIC ECONOMICS PUBLIC EDUCATION PUBLIC EXPENDITURE PUBLIC EXPENDITURES PUBLIC FINANCE PUBLIC GOODS PUBLIC INVESTMENTS PUBLIC POLICY REGRESSION RESULTS REVENUE RISING INEQUALITY RURAL RURAL CONSUMER RURAL ECONOMY RURAL EMPLOYMENT RURAL HOUSEHOLD RURAL HOUSEHOLDS RURAL INEQUALITY RURAL PUBLIC SAMPLING SCHOOL FINANCE SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCES SIGNIFICANT EFFECT SIGNIFICANT NEGATIVE SMALL BUSINESSES SOURCES OF INCOME SURVEY DESIGN TARGETING TAXATION TRANSFERS VILLAGE VILLAGE LEADERS VILLAGES WAGES This paper estimates the relationship between initial village inequality and subsequent household income growth for a large sample of households in rural China. Using a rich longitudinal survey spanning the years 1987-2002, and controlling for an array of household and village characteristics, the paper finds that households located in higher inequality villages experienced significantly lower income growth through the 1990s. However, local inequality s predictive power and effects are significantly diminished by the end of the sample. The paper exploits several advantages of the household-level data to explore hypotheses that shed light on the channels by which inequality affects growth. Biases due to aggregation and heterogeneity of returns to own-resources, previously suggested as candidate explanations for the relationship, are both ruled out. Instead, the evidence points to unobserved village institutions at the time of economic reforms that were associated with household access to higher income activities as the source of the link between inequality and growth. The empirical analysis addresses a number of pertinent econometric issues including measurement error and attrition, but underscores others that are likely to be intractable for all investigations of the inequality-growth relationship. 2012-03-19T18:42:58Z 2012-03-19T18:42:58Z 2010-11-01 http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/main?menuPK=64187510&pagePK=64193027&piPK=64187937&theSitePK=523679&menuPK=64187510&searchMenuPK=64187283&siteName=WDS&entityID=000158349_20101119093018 http://hdl.handle.net/10986/3964 English Policy Research working paper ; no. WPS 5483 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper East Asia and Pacific East Asia and Pacific East Asia Asia China