Evaluation of Government Performance and Public Policies in Spain
This paper covers selective aspects of Spain's experience in evaluating government performance and public policies. Rather than a cohesive evaluation system, there is instead a constellation of organizations, with evaluation mandates and/or pr...
| Main Authors: | , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Working Paper |
| Language: | English en_US |
| Published: |
Washington, DC: World Bank
2017
|
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/424771468103143549/Evaluation-of-government-performance-and-public-policies-in-Spain http://hdl.handle.net/10986/27913 |
| id |
okr-10986-27913 |
|---|---|
| recordtype |
oai_dc |
| repository_type |
Digital Repository |
| institution_category |
Foreign Institution |
| institution |
Digital Repositories |
| building |
World Bank Open Knowledge Repository |
| collection |
World Bank |
| language |
English en_US |
| topic |
ACCESS TO INFORMATION ACCOUNTABILITY ACCOUNTABILITY FOR RESULTS ACCOUNTING ALLOCATION ANNUAL BUDGET ANNUAL BUDGETING ANNUAL DEFICITS ANNUAL PLANS ANNUAL REPORT APPROPRIATIONS ARTICLE AUDITING AUDITORS BUDGET ALLOCATION BUDGET COMMISSION BUDGET DECISIONS BUDGET DISCUSSIONS BUDGET DOCUMENTS BUDGET PROCESS BUDGET PROPOSALS BUDGET REFORM BUDGET REFORMS BUDGET REQUESTS BUDGETARY DECISIONS BUDGETARY IMPLICATIONS BUDGETARY NEGOTIATIONS BUDGETARY POLICIES BUDGETARY PROCESS BUDGETARY PROGRAMS BUDGETARY RESOURCES BUDGETING PROCESS CAP CAPACITY BUILDING CENTRAL GOVERNMENT CITIES CLASSIFICATION OF EXPENDITURE COMPETENCIES CORRUPTION DECISION-MAKING DECISION-MAKING PROCESSES ECONOMIC POLICIES ECONOMIC POLICY EDUCATION SYSTEM EMPLOYMENT ENTITLEMENTS EVALUATION ACTIVITIES EVALUATION CAN EVALUATION CAPACITY EVALUATION GUIDELINES EVALUATION METHODS EVALUATION PRACTICES EVALUATION RESULTS EVALUATION STANDARDS EVALUATORS EX-POST EVALUATION EXAMINATIONS EXPENDITURE EXPENDITURE MANAGEMENT EXPENDITURE POLICIES EXPENDITURE POLICY EXPENDITURE PROGRAM EXPENDITURE PROGRAMS EXTERNAL ASSESSMENT EXTERNAL AUDIT FINANCE MANAGEMENT FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT FISCAL POLICIES FISCAL POLICY FISCAL RULES FORECASTS GOOD GOVERNANCE GOVERNMENT BUDGET GOVERNMENT EXPENDITURE GOVERNMENT PERFORMANCE GOVERNMENT POLICIES HEALTH PROGRAMS HUMAN RESOURCES IMPACT ASSESSMENT IMPACT EVALUATION IMPACT EVALUATIONS INTEGRATION INTERNAL CONTROL INTERVENTIONS INTERVIEWS LEARNING M&E SYSTEMS METHODOLOGIES METHODOLOGY MINISTRY OF CULTURE MINISTRY OF ECONOMY MINISTRY OF FINANCE MUNICIPALITIES MUSEUMS NATIONAL AGENCY NATIONAL BUDGET NATIONAL PARKS NATIONAL POLICIES NEGOTIATION ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURES PERFORMANCE AUDIT PERFORMANCE AUDITS PERFORMANCE BUDGET PERFORMANCE BUDGETING PERFORMANCE CULTURE PERFORMANCE EVALUATION PERFORMANCE INFORMATION PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT PERFORMANCE MEASURES PERFORMANCE REFORMS PERFORMANCE REPORTING PERSONNEL EXPENDITURES POLICY DECISIONS POLICY FORMULATION POLICY INITIATIVES PRIVATE INSURANCE PRIVATE SECTOR PRIVATE SECTOR INSTITUTIONS PROBABILITY PROGRAM ANALYSIS PROGRAM EVALUATION PROGRAMS PUBLIC ACCOUNTS PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION PUBLIC BUDGET PUBLIC DEBT PUBLIC EDUCATION PUBLIC ENTITIES PUBLIC EXPENDITURE PUBLIC FINANCE PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS PUBLIC INTERVENTION PUBLIC MANAGERS PUBLIC ORGANIZATIONS PUBLIC POLICIES PUBLIC RESOURCES PUBLIC SECTOR PUBLIC SECTOR BUDGET PUBLIC SECTOR EFFICIENCY PUBLIC SECTORS PUBLIC SERVICE PUBLIC SERVICES QUALITATIVE TOOLS QUALITY ASSURANCE QUALITY CONTROL QUALITY MANAGEMENT QUALITY OF PUBLIC SERVICES QUALITY OF SERVICES REFORM PLAN REFORM PROGRAM REGIONAL FUNDS REGIONAL GOVERNMENT REGIONAL GOVERNMENTS RESEARCH INSTITUTIONS RESEARCHERS RESOURCE ALLOCATION RESOURCE ALLOCATIONS SCENARIO SCENARIOS SCIENCES SECTOR MINISTRIES SECTOR MINISTRY SECTOR POLICY SECTOR PROGRAMS SELF-ASSESSMENT SERVICE PROVIDERS SERVICE PROVISION SERVICE QUALITY SOCIAL FUNDS SOCIAL POLICIES SOCIAL POLICY SOCIAL SECURITY SOCIAL SERVICES STATE AGENCIES STATE AGENCY STATE BUDGET STATED OBJECTIVES STRUCTURAL POLICIES SUPREME AUDIT INSTITUTIONS SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER TOTAL PUBLIC SECTOR TRANSPARENCY TRANSPARENT MANAGEMENT UNCERTAINTY VALIDITY |
| spellingShingle |
ACCESS TO INFORMATION ACCOUNTABILITY ACCOUNTABILITY FOR RESULTS ACCOUNTING ALLOCATION ANNUAL BUDGET ANNUAL BUDGETING ANNUAL DEFICITS ANNUAL PLANS ANNUAL REPORT APPROPRIATIONS ARTICLE AUDITING AUDITORS BUDGET ALLOCATION BUDGET COMMISSION BUDGET DECISIONS BUDGET DISCUSSIONS BUDGET DOCUMENTS BUDGET PROCESS BUDGET PROPOSALS BUDGET REFORM BUDGET REFORMS BUDGET REQUESTS BUDGETARY DECISIONS BUDGETARY IMPLICATIONS BUDGETARY NEGOTIATIONS BUDGETARY POLICIES BUDGETARY PROCESS BUDGETARY PROGRAMS BUDGETARY RESOURCES BUDGETING PROCESS CAP CAPACITY BUILDING CENTRAL GOVERNMENT CITIES CLASSIFICATION OF EXPENDITURE COMPETENCIES CORRUPTION DECISION-MAKING DECISION-MAKING PROCESSES ECONOMIC POLICIES ECONOMIC POLICY EDUCATION SYSTEM EMPLOYMENT ENTITLEMENTS EVALUATION ACTIVITIES EVALUATION CAN EVALUATION CAPACITY EVALUATION GUIDELINES EVALUATION METHODS EVALUATION PRACTICES EVALUATION RESULTS EVALUATION STANDARDS EVALUATORS EX-POST EVALUATION EXAMINATIONS EXPENDITURE EXPENDITURE MANAGEMENT EXPENDITURE POLICIES EXPENDITURE POLICY EXPENDITURE PROGRAM EXPENDITURE PROGRAMS EXTERNAL ASSESSMENT EXTERNAL AUDIT FINANCE MANAGEMENT FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT FISCAL POLICIES FISCAL POLICY FISCAL RULES FORECASTS GOOD GOVERNANCE GOVERNMENT BUDGET GOVERNMENT EXPENDITURE GOVERNMENT PERFORMANCE GOVERNMENT POLICIES HEALTH PROGRAMS HUMAN RESOURCES IMPACT ASSESSMENT IMPACT EVALUATION IMPACT EVALUATIONS INTEGRATION INTERNAL CONTROL INTERVENTIONS INTERVIEWS LEARNING M&E SYSTEMS METHODOLOGIES METHODOLOGY MINISTRY OF CULTURE MINISTRY OF ECONOMY MINISTRY OF FINANCE MUNICIPALITIES MUSEUMS NATIONAL AGENCY NATIONAL BUDGET NATIONAL PARKS NATIONAL POLICIES NEGOTIATION ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURES PERFORMANCE AUDIT PERFORMANCE AUDITS PERFORMANCE BUDGET PERFORMANCE BUDGETING PERFORMANCE CULTURE PERFORMANCE EVALUATION PERFORMANCE INFORMATION PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT PERFORMANCE MEASURES PERFORMANCE REFORMS PERFORMANCE REPORTING PERSONNEL EXPENDITURES POLICY DECISIONS POLICY FORMULATION POLICY INITIATIVES PRIVATE INSURANCE PRIVATE SECTOR PRIVATE SECTOR INSTITUTIONS PROBABILITY PROGRAM ANALYSIS PROGRAM EVALUATION PROGRAMS PUBLIC ACCOUNTS PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION PUBLIC BUDGET PUBLIC DEBT PUBLIC EDUCATION PUBLIC ENTITIES PUBLIC EXPENDITURE PUBLIC FINANCE PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS PUBLIC INTERVENTION PUBLIC MANAGERS PUBLIC ORGANIZATIONS PUBLIC POLICIES PUBLIC RESOURCES PUBLIC SECTOR PUBLIC SECTOR BUDGET PUBLIC SECTOR EFFICIENCY PUBLIC SECTORS PUBLIC SERVICE PUBLIC SERVICES QUALITATIVE TOOLS QUALITY ASSURANCE QUALITY CONTROL QUALITY MANAGEMENT QUALITY OF PUBLIC SERVICES QUALITY OF SERVICES REFORM PLAN REFORM PROGRAM REGIONAL FUNDS REGIONAL GOVERNMENT REGIONAL GOVERNMENTS RESEARCH INSTITUTIONS RESEARCHERS RESOURCE ALLOCATION RESOURCE ALLOCATIONS SCENARIO SCENARIOS SCIENCES SECTOR MINISTRIES SECTOR MINISTRY SECTOR POLICY SECTOR PROGRAMS SELF-ASSESSMENT SERVICE PROVIDERS SERVICE PROVISION SERVICE QUALITY SOCIAL FUNDS SOCIAL POLICIES SOCIAL POLICY SOCIAL SECURITY SOCIAL SERVICES STATE AGENCIES STATE AGENCY STATE BUDGET STATED OBJECTIVES STRUCTURAL POLICIES SUPREME AUDIT INSTITUTIONS SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER TOTAL PUBLIC SECTOR TRANSPARENCY TRANSPARENT MANAGEMENT UNCERTAINTY VALIDITY Feinstein, Osvaldo Zapico-Goni, Eduardo Evaluation of Government Performance and Public Policies in Spain |
| geographic_facet |
Europe and Central Asia Spain |
| relation |
ECD Working Paper Series;No. 22 |
| description |
This paper covers selective aspects of
Spain's experience in evaluating government performance
and public policies. Rather than a cohesive evaluation
system, there is instead a constellation of organizations,
with evaluation mandates and/or practices, which are not
interrelated. These organizations and their respective
practices have been evolving without coordination over the
past three decades. An evaluation culture is slowly
emerging, amid different conceptual approaches used by
different organizations that are managing and/or conducting
evaluations. Evaluation activity has been taking place in
Spain for years, with a marked acceleration and qualitative
shift since 2005. Despite Spain's standing as an
Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development
(OECD) country as well as a European Union (EU) country, it
still has not developed a consolidated evaluation system.
This fact points out how long-term and complex is the task
of institutionalizing an evaluation system. Finally, this
paper contains several website addresses where readers can
obtain additional information on aspects of the paper that
most interest them and to follow the Spanish experience as
it unfolds. |
| format |
Working Paper |
| author |
Feinstein, Osvaldo Zapico-Goni, Eduardo |
| author_facet |
Feinstein, Osvaldo Zapico-Goni, Eduardo |
| author_sort |
Feinstein, Osvaldo |
| title |
Evaluation of Government Performance and Public Policies in Spain |
| title_short |
Evaluation of Government Performance and Public Policies in Spain |
| title_full |
Evaluation of Government Performance and Public Policies in Spain |
| title_fullStr |
Evaluation of Government Performance and Public Policies in Spain |
| title_full_unstemmed |
Evaluation of Government Performance and Public Policies in Spain |
| title_sort |
evaluation of government performance and public policies in spain |
| publisher |
Washington, DC: World Bank |
| publishDate |
2017 |
| url |
http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/424771468103143549/Evaluation-of-government-performance-and-public-policies-in-Spain http://hdl.handle.net/10986/27913 |
| _version_ |
1764465061280088064 |
| spelling |
okr-10986-279132021-04-23T14:04:44Z Evaluation of Government Performance and Public Policies in Spain Feinstein, Osvaldo Zapico-Goni, Eduardo ACCESS TO INFORMATION ACCOUNTABILITY ACCOUNTABILITY FOR RESULTS ACCOUNTING ALLOCATION ANNUAL BUDGET ANNUAL BUDGETING ANNUAL DEFICITS ANNUAL PLANS ANNUAL REPORT APPROPRIATIONS ARTICLE AUDITING AUDITORS BUDGET ALLOCATION BUDGET COMMISSION BUDGET DECISIONS BUDGET DISCUSSIONS BUDGET DOCUMENTS BUDGET PROCESS BUDGET PROPOSALS BUDGET REFORM BUDGET REFORMS BUDGET REQUESTS BUDGETARY DECISIONS BUDGETARY IMPLICATIONS BUDGETARY NEGOTIATIONS BUDGETARY POLICIES BUDGETARY PROCESS BUDGETARY PROGRAMS BUDGETARY RESOURCES BUDGETING PROCESS CAP CAPACITY BUILDING CENTRAL GOVERNMENT CITIES CLASSIFICATION OF EXPENDITURE COMPETENCIES CORRUPTION DECISION-MAKING DECISION-MAKING PROCESSES ECONOMIC POLICIES ECONOMIC POLICY EDUCATION SYSTEM EMPLOYMENT ENTITLEMENTS EVALUATION ACTIVITIES EVALUATION CAN EVALUATION CAPACITY EVALUATION GUIDELINES EVALUATION METHODS EVALUATION PRACTICES EVALUATION RESULTS EVALUATION STANDARDS EVALUATORS EX-POST EVALUATION EXAMINATIONS EXPENDITURE EXPENDITURE MANAGEMENT EXPENDITURE POLICIES EXPENDITURE POLICY EXPENDITURE PROGRAM EXPENDITURE PROGRAMS EXTERNAL ASSESSMENT EXTERNAL AUDIT FINANCE MANAGEMENT FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT FISCAL POLICIES FISCAL POLICY FISCAL RULES FORECASTS GOOD GOVERNANCE GOVERNMENT BUDGET GOVERNMENT EXPENDITURE GOVERNMENT PERFORMANCE GOVERNMENT POLICIES HEALTH PROGRAMS HUMAN RESOURCES IMPACT ASSESSMENT IMPACT EVALUATION IMPACT EVALUATIONS INTEGRATION INTERNAL CONTROL INTERVENTIONS INTERVIEWS LEARNING M&E SYSTEMS METHODOLOGIES METHODOLOGY MINISTRY OF CULTURE MINISTRY OF ECONOMY MINISTRY OF FINANCE MUNICIPALITIES MUSEUMS NATIONAL AGENCY NATIONAL BUDGET NATIONAL PARKS NATIONAL POLICIES NEGOTIATION ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURES PERFORMANCE AUDIT PERFORMANCE AUDITS PERFORMANCE BUDGET PERFORMANCE BUDGETING PERFORMANCE CULTURE PERFORMANCE EVALUATION PERFORMANCE INFORMATION PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT PERFORMANCE MEASURES PERFORMANCE REFORMS PERFORMANCE REPORTING PERSONNEL EXPENDITURES POLICY DECISIONS POLICY FORMULATION POLICY INITIATIVES PRIVATE INSURANCE PRIVATE SECTOR PRIVATE SECTOR INSTITUTIONS PROBABILITY PROGRAM ANALYSIS PROGRAM EVALUATION PROGRAMS PUBLIC ACCOUNTS PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION PUBLIC BUDGET PUBLIC DEBT PUBLIC EDUCATION PUBLIC ENTITIES PUBLIC EXPENDITURE PUBLIC FINANCE PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS PUBLIC INTERVENTION PUBLIC MANAGERS PUBLIC ORGANIZATIONS PUBLIC POLICIES PUBLIC RESOURCES PUBLIC SECTOR PUBLIC SECTOR BUDGET PUBLIC SECTOR EFFICIENCY PUBLIC SECTORS PUBLIC SERVICE PUBLIC SERVICES QUALITATIVE TOOLS QUALITY ASSURANCE QUALITY CONTROL QUALITY MANAGEMENT QUALITY OF PUBLIC SERVICES QUALITY OF SERVICES REFORM PLAN REFORM PROGRAM REGIONAL FUNDS REGIONAL GOVERNMENT REGIONAL GOVERNMENTS RESEARCH INSTITUTIONS RESEARCHERS RESOURCE ALLOCATION RESOURCE ALLOCATIONS SCENARIO SCENARIOS SCIENCES SECTOR MINISTRIES SECTOR MINISTRY SECTOR POLICY SECTOR PROGRAMS SELF-ASSESSMENT SERVICE PROVIDERS SERVICE PROVISION SERVICE QUALITY SOCIAL FUNDS SOCIAL POLICIES SOCIAL POLICY SOCIAL SECURITY SOCIAL SERVICES STATE AGENCIES STATE AGENCY STATE BUDGET STATED OBJECTIVES STRUCTURAL POLICIES SUPREME AUDIT INSTITUTIONS SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER TOTAL PUBLIC SECTOR TRANSPARENCY TRANSPARENT MANAGEMENT UNCERTAINTY VALIDITY This paper covers selective aspects of Spain's experience in evaluating government performance and public policies. Rather than a cohesive evaluation system, there is instead a constellation of organizations, with evaluation mandates and/or practices, which are not interrelated. These organizations and their respective practices have been evolving without coordination over the past three decades. An evaluation culture is slowly emerging, amid different conceptual approaches used by different organizations that are managing and/or conducting evaluations. Evaluation activity has been taking place in Spain for years, with a marked acceleration and qualitative shift since 2005. Despite Spain's standing as an Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) country as well as a European Union (EU) country, it still has not developed a consolidated evaluation system. This fact points out how long-term and complex is the task of institutionalizing an evaluation system. Finally, this paper contains several website addresses where readers can obtain additional information on aspects of the paper that most interest them and to follow the Spanish experience as it unfolds. 2017-08-17T18:24:14Z 2017-08-17T18:24:14Z 2010-05 Working Paper http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/424771468103143549/Evaluation-of-government-performance-and-public-policies-in-Spain 978-1-60244-139-2 http://hdl.handle.net/10986/27913 English en_US ECD Working Paper Series;No. 22 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo World Bank Washington, DC: World Bank Publications & Research :: Working Paper Publications & Research Europe and Central Asia Spain |