Energy Efficiency Finance : Assessing the Impact of IFC's China Utility-based Energy Efficiency Finance Program

This evaluation assesses the performance of International Finance Corporations (IFC's) energy efficiency finance program in China aimed at stimulating energy efficiency investments through bank guarantees and technical assistance. The program&...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Independent Evaluation Group
Format: Publication
Language:English
Published: Washington, DC: World Bank 2012
Subjects:
AIR
CO
CO2
GHG
OIL
Online Access:http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/main?menuPK=64187510&pagePK=64193027&piPK=64187937&theSitePK=523679&menuPK=64187510&searchMenuPK=64187283&siteName=WDS&entityID=000334955_20100706060737
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/2480
id okr-10986-2480
recordtype oai_dc
repository_type Digital Repository
institution_category Foreign Institution
institution Digital Repositories
building World Bank Open Knowledge Repository
collection World Bank
language English
topic ACCESS TO CREDIT
ACCESS TO ENERGY
ACCESS TO FINANCE
ACCESS TO FINANCING
ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS
ADVANCED TECHNOLOGIES
ADVISORY SERVICES
AIR
ANNUAL EMISSIONS
APPROACH
AVAILABILITY
BALANCE SHEET
BANK FINANCING
BANK LENDING
BANK LOANS
BANKS
BARRIERS TO ENERGY EFFICIENCY
BASES
BENEFIT STREAMS
BIOMASS
BORROWER
CALCULATION
CALORIFIC VALUE
CAPACITY BUILDING
CARBON
CARBON CONTENT
CARBON DIOXIDE
CARBON EMISSION
CASH FLOWS
CEMENT
CEMENT PRODUCTION
CLEAN DEVELOPMENT MECHANISMS
CLEANER ENERGY
CLIMATE
CLIMATE CHANGE
CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION
CLIMATE POLICY
CO
CO2
COAL
COAL COMBUSTION
COAL CONSUMPTION
COAL ENERGY
COAL PRODUCTION
COGENERATION
COLLATERAL
COLLATERAL REQUIREMENTS
COLORS
COMMERCIAL BANKS
COMMERCIAL ENERGY
COMMERCIAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY
COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS
CREDIT DECISIONS
CREDIT LINE
CREDIT RISK
DEMAND CURVE
DEMAND FOR COAL
DEMAND FOR ENERGY
DEVELOPMENT ASSISTANCE
DISCOUNT RATES
DOWN MARKET
DOWN PAYMENTS
ECONOMIC BENEFITS
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMIC IMPACTS
EFFICIENCY GAINS
EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENT
EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENTS
EFFICIENCY POTENTIAL
ELECTRICITY
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA
EMISSION
EMISSION INTENSITY
EMISSION REDUCTION
EMISSION REDUCTION TARGETS
EMISSION REDUCTIONS
EMISSIONS
EMISSIONS INTENSITY
ENERGY BALANCE
ENERGY CONSERVATION
ENERGY CONSUMERS
ENERGY CONSUMPTION
ENERGY COST SAVINGS
ENERGY DEMAND
ENERGY EFFICIENCY
ENERGY EFFICIENCY FINANCE
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENTS
ENERGY EFFICIENCY INVESTMENTS
ENERGY EFFICIENCY MEASURES
ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROGRAMS
ENERGY GENERATION
ENERGY INDUSTRIES
ENERGY INPUT
ENERGY INTENSITY
ENERGY MANAGEMENT
ENERGY POLICY
ENERGY PRICES
ENERGY PRICING
ENERGY SAVINGS
ENERGY SAVINGS PERFORMANCE
ENERGY SOURCES
ENERGY SUPPLY
ENERGY USAGE
ENERGY USE
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS
ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY
EXPLOSIVE
FINANCIAL CRISIS
FINANCIAL INCENTIVES
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARIES
FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARY
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FINANCIAL RETURN
FIXED ASSET
FOREIGN EXCHANGE
FOSSIL
FOSSIL FUEL
FOSSIL FUEL USE
FOSSIL FUELS
FUEL
FUEL USE
FUNDING SOURCES
GAS DISTRIBUTION
GAS UTILITIES
GAS UTILITY
GHG
GHGS
GLOBAL CLIMATE CHANGE
GLOBAL ENVIRONMENT FACILITY
GLOBAL WARMING
GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION
GOVERNMENT POLICIES
GOVERNMENT POLICY
GREATER ACCESS
GREENHOUSE
GREENHOUSE GAS
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSION
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS
GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT
GUARANTEE AGENCY
HEAT
HEAT RECOVERY
HEATING SYSTEMS
HYDROPOWER
IMPROVING ENERGY EFFICIENCY
INDUSTRIAL BOILER
INDUSTRIAL WASTE
INFORMATION GAP
INSURANCE
INSURANCE PRODUCTS
INTEREST RATE
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INTERNATIONAL FINANCE
INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES
INVESTMENTS IN ENERGY
INVESTMENTS IN ENERGY EFFICIENCY
IPCC
KEY CHALLENGE
LACK OF AWARENESS
LACK OF CREDIT
LENDING PORTFOLIO
LIMITED ACCESS
LIMITED ACCESS TO FINANCE
LOAN
LOAN AMOUNT
LOAN GUARANTEE
LOAN GUARANTEES
LOAN PORTFOLIO
LOAN PRODUCTS
LOAN REPAYMENTS
LOAN SIZE
MARKET DEVELOPMENT
MARKET FAILURE
MARKET FAILURES
METHANE
NATURAL GAS
NEW BUSINESS
NITROGEN
NITROGEN OXIDE
NITROUS OXIDE
OIL
OUTREACH
PARTICULATE
PARTICULATE MATTER
PARTNER BANKS
PETROLEUM
PETROLEUM USE
POLICY ENVIRONMENTS
POLICY MAKERS
POLLUTION
PORTFOLIO
POWER
POWER GENERATION
POWER PLANTS
PROMOTING ENERGY EFFICIENCY
RADIATION
RATES OF RETURN
REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
RENEWABLE ENERGIES
RENEWABLE ENERGY
RENEWABLE ENERGY INDUSTRIES
RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURCES
RENEWABLE SOURCES
RESIDENTIAL HOUSING
RETROFITTING
RISK AVERSION
SMALL ENTERPRISES
SOURCE OF ENERGY
SPILLOVER EFFECTS
SULFUR
SUPPLY CURVE
SUSTAINABLE ENERGY
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
TONS OF COAL EQUIVALENT
TRANSACTION COSTS
UNION
WIND
WIND FARMS
WIND SYSTEMS
spellingShingle ACCESS TO CREDIT
ACCESS TO ENERGY
ACCESS TO FINANCE
ACCESS TO FINANCING
ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS
ADVANCED TECHNOLOGIES
ADVISORY SERVICES
AIR
ANNUAL EMISSIONS
APPROACH
AVAILABILITY
BALANCE SHEET
BANK FINANCING
BANK LENDING
BANK LOANS
BANKS
BARRIERS TO ENERGY EFFICIENCY
BASES
BENEFIT STREAMS
BIOMASS
BORROWER
CALCULATION
CALORIFIC VALUE
CAPACITY BUILDING
CARBON
CARBON CONTENT
CARBON DIOXIDE
CARBON EMISSION
CASH FLOWS
CEMENT
CEMENT PRODUCTION
CLEAN DEVELOPMENT MECHANISMS
CLEANER ENERGY
CLIMATE
CLIMATE CHANGE
CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION
CLIMATE POLICY
CO
CO2
COAL
COAL COMBUSTION
COAL CONSUMPTION
COAL ENERGY
COAL PRODUCTION
COGENERATION
COLLATERAL
COLLATERAL REQUIREMENTS
COLORS
COMMERCIAL BANKS
COMMERCIAL ENERGY
COMMERCIAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY
COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS
CREDIT DECISIONS
CREDIT LINE
CREDIT RISK
DEMAND CURVE
DEMAND FOR COAL
DEMAND FOR ENERGY
DEVELOPMENT ASSISTANCE
DISCOUNT RATES
DOWN MARKET
DOWN PAYMENTS
ECONOMIC BENEFITS
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMIC IMPACTS
EFFICIENCY GAINS
EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENT
EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENTS
EFFICIENCY POTENTIAL
ELECTRICITY
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA
EMISSION
EMISSION INTENSITY
EMISSION REDUCTION
EMISSION REDUCTION TARGETS
EMISSION REDUCTIONS
EMISSIONS
EMISSIONS INTENSITY
ENERGY BALANCE
ENERGY CONSERVATION
ENERGY CONSUMERS
ENERGY CONSUMPTION
ENERGY COST SAVINGS
ENERGY DEMAND
ENERGY EFFICIENCY
ENERGY EFFICIENCY FINANCE
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENTS
ENERGY EFFICIENCY INVESTMENTS
ENERGY EFFICIENCY MEASURES
ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROGRAMS
ENERGY GENERATION
ENERGY INDUSTRIES
ENERGY INPUT
ENERGY INTENSITY
ENERGY MANAGEMENT
ENERGY POLICY
ENERGY PRICES
ENERGY PRICING
ENERGY SAVINGS
ENERGY SAVINGS PERFORMANCE
ENERGY SOURCES
ENERGY SUPPLY
ENERGY USAGE
ENERGY USE
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS
ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY
EXPLOSIVE
FINANCIAL CRISIS
FINANCIAL INCENTIVES
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARIES
FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARY
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FINANCIAL RETURN
FIXED ASSET
FOREIGN EXCHANGE
FOSSIL
FOSSIL FUEL
FOSSIL FUEL USE
FOSSIL FUELS
FUEL
FUEL USE
FUNDING SOURCES
GAS DISTRIBUTION
GAS UTILITIES
GAS UTILITY
GHG
GHGS
GLOBAL CLIMATE CHANGE
GLOBAL ENVIRONMENT FACILITY
GLOBAL WARMING
GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION
GOVERNMENT POLICIES
GOVERNMENT POLICY
GREATER ACCESS
GREENHOUSE
GREENHOUSE GAS
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSION
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS
GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT
GUARANTEE AGENCY
HEAT
HEAT RECOVERY
HEATING SYSTEMS
HYDROPOWER
IMPROVING ENERGY EFFICIENCY
INDUSTRIAL BOILER
INDUSTRIAL WASTE
INFORMATION GAP
INSURANCE
INSURANCE PRODUCTS
INTEREST RATE
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INTERNATIONAL FINANCE
INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES
INVESTMENTS IN ENERGY
INVESTMENTS IN ENERGY EFFICIENCY
IPCC
KEY CHALLENGE
LACK OF AWARENESS
LACK OF CREDIT
LENDING PORTFOLIO
LIMITED ACCESS
LIMITED ACCESS TO FINANCE
LOAN
LOAN AMOUNT
LOAN GUARANTEE
LOAN GUARANTEES
LOAN PORTFOLIO
LOAN PRODUCTS
LOAN REPAYMENTS
LOAN SIZE
MARKET DEVELOPMENT
MARKET FAILURE
MARKET FAILURES
METHANE
NATURAL GAS
NEW BUSINESS
NITROGEN
NITROGEN OXIDE
NITROUS OXIDE
OIL
OUTREACH
PARTICULATE
PARTICULATE MATTER
PARTNER BANKS
PETROLEUM
PETROLEUM USE
POLICY ENVIRONMENTS
POLICY MAKERS
POLLUTION
PORTFOLIO
POWER
POWER GENERATION
POWER PLANTS
PROMOTING ENERGY EFFICIENCY
RADIATION
RATES OF RETURN
REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
RENEWABLE ENERGIES
RENEWABLE ENERGY
RENEWABLE ENERGY INDUSTRIES
RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURCES
RENEWABLE SOURCES
RESIDENTIAL HOUSING
RETROFITTING
RISK AVERSION
SMALL ENTERPRISES
SOURCE OF ENERGY
SPILLOVER EFFECTS
SULFUR
SUPPLY CURVE
SUSTAINABLE ENERGY
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
TONS OF COAL EQUIVALENT
TRANSACTION COSTS
UNION
WIND
WIND FARMS
WIND SYSTEMS
Independent Evaluation Group
Energy Efficiency Finance : Assessing the Impact of IFC's China Utility-based Energy Efficiency Finance Program
geographic_facet East Asia
Asia
China
relation IEG study series
description This evaluation assesses the performance of International Finance Corporations (IFC's) energy efficiency finance program in China aimed at stimulating energy efficiency investments through bank guarantees and technical assistance. The program's significance is underpinned by the fact that China's size, rapid economic growth, and inefficiencies in energy use make it one of the world's largest emitters of carbon dioxide (CO2.). The utilization of IFC's program has been rapid compared with other similar programs. The difference made by the program is traced along the chain of interventions: (i) at the level of banks, the program is narrowly based on one of the two partner banks, which, with the help of the program, expanded its energy efficiency lending as a new business line; (ii) at the level of energy management companies, the program's technical assistance improved the program participants' access to finance; and (iii) at the end-user level, it promoted the use of energy efficiency investments that achieved reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. The evaluation recommends areas of improvement to realize greater impact. First, the program needs to emphasize areas where the potential additionality is high, such as small enterprises. Second, the program needs to concentrate more on activities that have the potential to reduce emissions significantly, such as energy efficiency for buildings. Third, the program's subsidy elements need to be reoriented to the areas of market failure, with IFC increasing its coverage of first loss from its own resources.
format Publications & Research :: Publication
author Independent Evaluation Group
author_facet Independent Evaluation Group
author_sort Independent Evaluation Group
title Energy Efficiency Finance : Assessing the Impact of IFC's China Utility-based Energy Efficiency Finance Program
title_short Energy Efficiency Finance : Assessing the Impact of IFC's China Utility-based Energy Efficiency Finance Program
title_full Energy Efficiency Finance : Assessing the Impact of IFC's China Utility-based Energy Efficiency Finance Program
title_fullStr Energy Efficiency Finance : Assessing the Impact of IFC's China Utility-based Energy Efficiency Finance Program
title_full_unstemmed Energy Efficiency Finance : Assessing the Impact of IFC's China Utility-based Energy Efficiency Finance Program
title_sort energy efficiency finance : assessing the impact of ifc's china utility-based energy efficiency finance program
publisher Washington, DC: World Bank
publishDate 2012
url http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/main?menuPK=64187510&pagePK=64193027&piPK=64187937&theSitePK=523679&menuPK=64187510&searchMenuPK=64187283&siteName=WDS&entityID=000334955_20100706060737
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/2480
_version_ 1764385525255372800
spelling okr-10986-24802021-04-23T14:02:02Z Energy Efficiency Finance : Assessing the Impact of IFC's China Utility-based Energy Efficiency Finance Program Independent Evaluation Group ACCESS TO CREDIT ACCESS TO ENERGY ACCESS TO FINANCE ACCESS TO FINANCING ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS ADVANCED TECHNOLOGIES ADVISORY SERVICES AIR ANNUAL EMISSIONS APPROACH AVAILABILITY BALANCE SHEET BANK FINANCING BANK LENDING BANK LOANS BANKS BARRIERS TO ENERGY EFFICIENCY BASES BENEFIT STREAMS BIOMASS BORROWER CALCULATION CALORIFIC VALUE CAPACITY BUILDING CARBON CARBON CONTENT CARBON DIOXIDE CARBON EMISSION CASH FLOWS CEMENT CEMENT PRODUCTION CLEAN DEVELOPMENT MECHANISMS CLEANER ENERGY CLIMATE CLIMATE CHANGE CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION CLIMATE POLICY CO CO2 COAL COAL COMBUSTION COAL CONSUMPTION COAL ENERGY COAL PRODUCTION COGENERATION COLLATERAL COLLATERAL REQUIREMENTS COLORS COMMERCIAL BANKS COMMERCIAL ENERGY COMMERCIAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS CREDIT DECISIONS CREDIT LINE CREDIT RISK DEMAND CURVE DEMAND FOR COAL DEMAND FOR ENERGY DEVELOPMENT ASSISTANCE DISCOUNT RATES DOWN MARKET DOWN PAYMENTS ECONOMIC BENEFITS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ECONOMIC GROWTH ECONOMIC IMPACTS EFFICIENCY GAINS EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENT EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENTS EFFICIENCY POTENTIAL ELECTRICITY ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA EMISSION EMISSION INTENSITY EMISSION REDUCTION EMISSION REDUCTION TARGETS EMISSION REDUCTIONS EMISSIONS EMISSIONS INTENSITY ENERGY BALANCE ENERGY CONSERVATION ENERGY CONSUMERS ENERGY CONSUMPTION ENERGY COST SAVINGS ENERGY DEMAND ENERGY EFFICIENCY ENERGY EFFICIENCY FINANCE ENERGY EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENTS ENERGY EFFICIENCY INVESTMENTS ENERGY EFFICIENCY MEASURES ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROGRAMS ENERGY GENERATION ENERGY INDUSTRIES ENERGY INPUT ENERGY INTENSITY ENERGY MANAGEMENT ENERGY POLICY ENERGY PRICES ENERGY PRICING ENERGY SAVINGS ENERGY SAVINGS PERFORMANCE ENERGY SOURCES ENERGY SUPPLY ENERGY USAGE ENERGY USE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY EXPLOSIVE FINANCIAL CRISIS FINANCIAL INCENTIVES FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARIES FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARY FINANCIAL MARKETS FINANCIAL RETURN FIXED ASSET FOREIGN EXCHANGE FOSSIL FOSSIL FUEL FOSSIL FUEL USE FOSSIL FUELS FUEL FUEL USE FUNDING SOURCES GAS DISTRIBUTION GAS UTILITIES GAS UTILITY GHG GHGS GLOBAL CLIMATE CHANGE GLOBAL ENVIRONMENT FACILITY GLOBAL WARMING GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION GOVERNMENT POLICIES GOVERNMENT POLICY GREATER ACCESS GREENHOUSE GREENHOUSE GAS GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSION GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT GUARANTEE AGENCY HEAT HEAT RECOVERY HEATING SYSTEMS HYDROPOWER IMPROVING ENERGY EFFICIENCY INDUSTRIAL BOILER INDUSTRIAL WASTE INFORMATION GAP INSURANCE INSURANCE PRODUCTS INTEREST RATE INTERNATIONAL BANK INTERNATIONAL FINANCE INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES INVESTMENTS IN ENERGY INVESTMENTS IN ENERGY EFFICIENCY IPCC KEY CHALLENGE LACK OF AWARENESS LACK OF CREDIT LENDING PORTFOLIO LIMITED ACCESS LIMITED ACCESS TO FINANCE LOAN LOAN AMOUNT LOAN GUARANTEE LOAN GUARANTEES LOAN PORTFOLIO LOAN PRODUCTS LOAN REPAYMENTS LOAN SIZE MARKET DEVELOPMENT MARKET FAILURE MARKET FAILURES METHANE NATURAL GAS NEW BUSINESS NITROGEN NITROGEN OXIDE NITROUS OXIDE OIL OUTREACH PARTICULATE PARTICULATE MATTER PARTNER BANKS PETROLEUM PETROLEUM USE POLICY ENVIRONMENTS POLICY MAKERS POLLUTION PORTFOLIO POWER POWER GENERATION POWER PLANTS PROMOTING ENERGY EFFICIENCY RADIATION RATES OF RETURN REGULATORY FRAMEWORK RENEWABLE ENERGIES RENEWABLE ENERGY RENEWABLE ENERGY INDUSTRIES RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURCES RENEWABLE SOURCES RESIDENTIAL HOUSING RETROFITTING RISK AVERSION SMALL ENTERPRISES SOURCE OF ENERGY SPILLOVER EFFECTS SULFUR SUPPLY CURVE SUSTAINABLE ENERGY TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TONS OF COAL EQUIVALENT TRANSACTION COSTS UNION WIND WIND FARMS WIND SYSTEMS This evaluation assesses the performance of International Finance Corporations (IFC's) energy efficiency finance program in China aimed at stimulating energy efficiency investments through bank guarantees and technical assistance. The program's significance is underpinned by the fact that China's size, rapid economic growth, and inefficiencies in energy use make it one of the world's largest emitters of carbon dioxide (CO2.). The utilization of IFC's program has been rapid compared with other similar programs. The difference made by the program is traced along the chain of interventions: (i) at the level of banks, the program is narrowly based on one of the two partner banks, which, with the help of the program, expanded its energy efficiency lending as a new business line; (ii) at the level of energy management companies, the program's technical assistance improved the program participants' access to finance; and (iii) at the end-user level, it promoted the use of energy efficiency investments that achieved reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. The evaluation recommends areas of improvement to realize greater impact. First, the program needs to emphasize areas where the potential additionality is high, such as small enterprises. Second, the program needs to concentrate more on activities that have the potential to reduce emissions significantly, such as energy efficiency for buildings. Third, the program's subsidy elements need to be reoriented to the areas of market failure, with IFC increasing its coverage of first loss from its own resources. 2012-03-19T09:34:35Z 2012-03-19T09:34:35Z 2010 http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/main?menuPK=64187510&pagePK=64193027&piPK=64187937&theSitePK=523679&menuPK=64187510&searchMenuPK=64187283&siteName=WDS&entityID=000334955_20100706060737 978-0-8213-8450-3 http://hdl.handle.net/10986/2480 English IEG study series CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank Washington, DC: World Bank Publications & Research :: Publication Publications & Research :: Publication East Asia Asia China