Responding to Global Public Bads : Learning from Evaluation of the World Bank Experience with Avian Influenza 2006-13

The World Bank’s efforts to combat avian influenza and help countries to build capacity to prevent and mitigate pandemics offers a useful example in understanding how the agency can contribute to the provision of global public goods. This review ai...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Independent Evaluation Group
Format: Evaluation
Language:English
en_US
Published: World Bank, Washington, DC 2016
Subjects:
M&E
H5
Online Access:http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2016/04/26249213/responding-global-public-bads-learning-evaluation-world-bank-experience-avian-influenza-2006-13
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/24131
id okr-10986-24131
recordtype oai_dc
repository_type Digital Repository
institution_category Foreign Institution
institution Digital Repositories
building World Bank Open Knowledge Repository
collection World Bank
language English
en_US
topic INFLUENZA INFECTION
STRAINS OF INFLUENZA
DISEASE CONTAINMENT
VETERINARY SERVICES
HEALTH PLANNING
LABORATORY FACILITIES
VACCINATION
AVIAN FLU
PROTEIN
COMMERCIAL POULTRY PRODUCTION
VETERINARY AGENCIES
SAMPLE COLLECTION
ANTIVIRAL
DEATH
ANIMAL HEALTH ISSUES
DISEASE SURVEILLANCE SYSTEMS
VETERINARY AGENCY
DISEASE REPORTING
AVIAN INFLUENZA PROJECT
HEALTH EMERGENCIES
COMMUNICATION MATERIALS
HOSPITAL
ANIMAL HEALTH
AVIAN INFLUENZA RESPONSE
ACUTE RESPIRATORY SYNDROME
HANDLING
INFLUENZA SURVEILLANCE
PREPAREDNESS ACTIVITIES
PANDEMIC THREAT
LABORATORY WASTE
SECTORAL STRATEGY
ZOONOTIC DISEASES
ANIMAL HEALTH SURVEILLANCE
DISEASE EMERGENCIES
CHICKENS
HUMAN INFLUENZA
RESPONSE PLANS
LABORATORIES
DISEASE RISKS
ANTIVIRAL DRUGS
ANIMAL DEATH
INFECTIOUS DISEASE EMERGENCIES
BIRD
FARMERS
LIVE BIRD
EPIDEMICS
RESPIRATORY DISEASE
BIRD POPULATIONS
DISEASE OUTBREAKS
OUTBREAKS OF AVIAN INFLUENZA
PANDEMIC STRAIN
PATHOGENIC AVIAN INFLUENZA
HUMAN PANDEMIC
DISASTER RISK MANAGEMENT
AVIAN INFLUENZA INFECTION
PANDEMIC RESPONSE
WILD BIRDS
AVIAN INFLUENZA OUTBREAKS
CONFIRMED HUMAN CASES
TRADE IN LIVESTOCK
HPAI
HOSTS
PANDEMIC PREPAREDNESS
EMERGING INFECTIOUS DISEASES
ISOLATION WARDS
SMALLHOLDER FARMERS
LIVESTOCK SECTORS
ANIMAL HEALTH SPECIALISTS
WILD BIRD MIGRATION
LIVESTOCK SPECIALISTS
INFECTION IN HUMANS
HEALTH SURVEILLANCE
POULTRY DENSITY
BURDEN OF DISEASE
BORDER CONTROL
ANIMAL HEALTH AGENCIES
ANIMAL HEALTH COMPONENTS
FOOD SAFETY
RESPONSE CAPACITY
DISEASE IN BIRDS
ANIMAL DISEASE OUTBREAKS
SITES FOR DISPOSAL
FEED
DISEASE RISK
INDUSTRIAL POULTRY PRODUCTION
DISINFECTANT
LABORATORY
M&E
VACCINE
HEALTH INTERVENTIONS
RISK ASSESSMENTS
HUMAN CASES OF AVIAN INFLUENZA
BIOSECURITY
ENVIRONMENTAL SAFEGUARDS
POULTRY
POULTRY VACCINATION
DIAGNOSIS
WILD BIRD POPULATIONS
BIRDS
DEATHS
INFLUENZA PANDEMIC
SICK BIRDS
AGRICULTURE MINISTRY
CULLED
INFLUENZA EMERGENCY
AVIAN INFLUENZA CONTROL
HEMORRHAGIC FEVER
POULTRY FARMS
MONITORING AND EVALUATION
OUTBREAKS
INFLUENZA PLANS
AVIAN INFLUENZA EMERGENCY
AGRICULTURE ORGANIZATION
DISEASED BIRDS
PUBLIC HEALTH
INFLUENZA PANDEMICS
INFECTIOUS DISEASE
STRAIN
TYPES OF BIRDS
EMERGENCY INTERVENTIONS
INFLUENZA RESPONSE
MOVEMENT OF BIRDS
PANDEMIC
SECTORAL STRATEGIES
CONTAINMENT
ANIMAL DISEASES
RESPONSE PLANNING
AIR TRAVEL
POULTRY SECTOR
INFECTIOUS DISEASES
WORST CASE SCENARIOS
LABORATORY EQUIPMENT
LIVE BIRD MARKETS
DIAGNOSTIC SYSTEMS
MIGRATION
ANIMAL DEATHS
ANIMAL DISEASE
BACKYARD FARMERS
ZOONOTIC DISEASE
PERSONAL PROTECTIVE EQUIPMENT
LIVESTOCK PRODUCERS
LIVESTOCK
DISEASE SPREAD
OUTBREAK
EMERGENCY SUPPLIES
REAGENTS
COMMERCIAL FARMS
POULTRY PRODUCTION
DISEASE PREVENTION
DIAGNOSTIC TESTS
AVIAN INFLUENZA PROJECTS
HUMAN INFECTIONS
POULTRY SECTORS
MUTATIONS
FOOD SECURITY
LIVESTOCK SECTOR
BACKYARD POULTRY SYSTEMS
INFLUENZA
DOMESTIC POULTRY
HUMAN HEALTH OUTCOMES
PANDEMICS
SURVEILLANCE
INFECTION OF HUMANS
DISEASE MANAGEMENT
ANIMAL HEALTH SYSTEMS
EMERGENCY RECOVERY
VIROLOGY
AVIAN INFLUENZA CRISIS
SWINE
BIRD MIGRATION
WILD BIRD
H5
spellingShingle INFLUENZA INFECTION
STRAINS OF INFLUENZA
DISEASE CONTAINMENT
VETERINARY SERVICES
HEALTH PLANNING
LABORATORY FACILITIES
VACCINATION
AVIAN FLU
PROTEIN
COMMERCIAL POULTRY PRODUCTION
VETERINARY AGENCIES
SAMPLE COLLECTION
ANTIVIRAL
DEATH
ANIMAL HEALTH ISSUES
DISEASE SURVEILLANCE SYSTEMS
VETERINARY AGENCY
DISEASE REPORTING
AVIAN INFLUENZA PROJECT
HEALTH EMERGENCIES
COMMUNICATION MATERIALS
HOSPITAL
ANIMAL HEALTH
AVIAN INFLUENZA RESPONSE
ACUTE RESPIRATORY SYNDROME
HANDLING
INFLUENZA SURVEILLANCE
PREPAREDNESS ACTIVITIES
PANDEMIC THREAT
LABORATORY WASTE
SECTORAL STRATEGY
ZOONOTIC DISEASES
ANIMAL HEALTH SURVEILLANCE
DISEASE EMERGENCIES
CHICKENS
HUMAN INFLUENZA
RESPONSE PLANS
LABORATORIES
DISEASE RISKS
ANTIVIRAL DRUGS
ANIMAL DEATH
INFECTIOUS DISEASE EMERGENCIES
BIRD
FARMERS
LIVE BIRD
EPIDEMICS
RESPIRATORY DISEASE
BIRD POPULATIONS
DISEASE OUTBREAKS
OUTBREAKS OF AVIAN INFLUENZA
PANDEMIC STRAIN
PATHOGENIC AVIAN INFLUENZA
HUMAN PANDEMIC
DISASTER RISK MANAGEMENT
AVIAN INFLUENZA INFECTION
PANDEMIC RESPONSE
WILD BIRDS
AVIAN INFLUENZA OUTBREAKS
CONFIRMED HUMAN CASES
TRADE IN LIVESTOCK
HPAI
HOSTS
PANDEMIC PREPAREDNESS
EMERGING INFECTIOUS DISEASES
ISOLATION WARDS
SMALLHOLDER FARMERS
LIVESTOCK SECTORS
ANIMAL HEALTH SPECIALISTS
WILD BIRD MIGRATION
LIVESTOCK SPECIALISTS
INFECTION IN HUMANS
HEALTH SURVEILLANCE
POULTRY DENSITY
BURDEN OF DISEASE
BORDER CONTROL
ANIMAL HEALTH AGENCIES
ANIMAL HEALTH COMPONENTS
FOOD SAFETY
RESPONSE CAPACITY
DISEASE IN BIRDS
ANIMAL DISEASE OUTBREAKS
SITES FOR DISPOSAL
FEED
DISEASE RISK
INDUSTRIAL POULTRY PRODUCTION
DISINFECTANT
LABORATORY
M&E
VACCINE
HEALTH INTERVENTIONS
RISK ASSESSMENTS
HUMAN CASES OF AVIAN INFLUENZA
BIOSECURITY
ENVIRONMENTAL SAFEGUARDS
POULTRY
POULTRY VACCINATION
DIAGNOSIS
WILD BIRD POPULATIONS
BIRDS
DEATHS
INFLUENZA PANDEMIC
SICK BIRDS
AGRICULTURE MINISTRY
CULLED
INFLUENZA EMERGENCY
AVIAN INFLUENZA CONTROL
HEMORRHAGIC FEVER
POULTRY FARMS
MONITORING AND EVALUATION
OUTBREAKS
INFLUENZA PLANS
AVIAN INFLUENZA EMERGENCY
AGRICULTURE ORGANIZATION
DISEASED BIRDS
PUBLIC HEALTH
INFLUENZA PANDEMICS
INFECTIOUS DISEASE
STRAIN
TYPES OF BIRDS
EMERGENCY INTERVENTIONS
INFLUENZA RESPONSE
MOVEMENT OF BIRDS
PANDEMIC
SECTORAL STRATEGIES
CONTAINMENT
ANIMAL DISEASES
RESPONSE PLANNING
AIR TRAVEL
POULTRY SECTOR
INFECTIOUS DISEASES
WORST CASE SCENARIOS
LABORATORY EQUIPMENT
LIVE BIRD MARKETS
DIAGNOSTIC SYSTEMS
MIGRATION
ANIMAL DEATHS
ANIMAL DISEASE
BACKYARD FARMERS
ZOONOTIC DISEASE
PERSONAL PROTECTIVE EQUIPMENT
LIVESTOCK PRODUCERS
LIVESTOCK
DISEASE SPREAD
OUTBREAK
EMERGENCY SUPPLIES
REAGENTS
COMMERCIAL FARMS
POULTRY PRODUCTION
DISEASE PREVENTION
DIAGNOSTIC TESTS
AVIAN INFLUENZA PROJECTS
HUMAN INFECTIONS
POULTRY SECTORS
MUTATIONS
FOOD SECURITY
LIVESTOCK SECTOR
BACKYARD POULTRY SYSTEMS
INFLUENZA
DOMESTIC POULTRY
HUMAN HEALTH OUTCOMES
PANDEMICS
SURVEILLANCE
INFECTION OF HUMANS
DISEASE MANAGEMENT
ANIMAL HEALTH SYSTEMS
EMERGENCY RECOVERY
VIROLOGY
AVIAN INFLUENZA CRISIS
SWINE
BIRD MIGRATION
WILD BIRD
H5
Independent Evaluation Group
Responding to Global Public Bads : Learning from Evaluation of the World Bank Experience with Avian Influenza 2006-13
description The World Bank’s efforts to combat avian influenza and help countries to build capacity to prevent and mitigate pandemics offers a useful example in understanding how the agency can contribute to the provision of global public goods. This review aims to inform the provision of these goods by offering lessons from evaluation of the avian influenza experience. The experience also offers an example of the Bank playing a key role in the international response to an unfolding international crisis in a technical area with which it was largely unfamiliar. And provides a case study on how the Bank struggles to work effectively across sectors, both within the institution itself and in the client countries it operates in. The report aims to inform the design of any future avian influenza and zoonotic disease and pandemic preparedness interventions, and also to discuss the wider strategic lessons from the intervention that are relevant to programs responding to emergencies, providing global public goods, or cooperating with external technical agencies. The report also aims to assess the current state of the pandemic preparedness agenda, and to provide guidance on possible ways forward. The report also draws on additional interviews with Bank staff and international agency staff, on World Bank project and program documentation and reports, on the wider literature on avian influenza, and on other documents.
format Evaluation
author Independent Evaluation Group
author_facet Independent Evaluation Group
author_sort Independent Evaluation Group
title Responding to Global Public Bads : Learning from Evaluation of the World Bank Experience with Avian Influenza 2006-13
title_short Responding to Global Public Bads : Learning from Evaluation of the World Bank Experience with Avian Influenza 2006-13
title_full Responding to Global Public Bads : Learning from Evaluation of the World Bank Experience with Avian Influenza 2006-13
title_fullStr Responding to Global Public Bads : Learning from Evaluation of the World Bank Experience with Avian Influenza 2006-13
title_full_unstemmed Responding to Global Public Bads : Learning from Evaluation of the World Bank Experience with Avian Influenza 2006-13
title_sort responding to global public bads : learning from evaluation of the world bank experience with avian influenza 2006-13
publisher World Bank, Washington, DC
publishDate 2016
url http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2016/04/26249213/responding-global-public-bads-learning-evaluation-world-bank-experience-avian-influenza-2006-13
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/24131
_version_ 1764455729754800128
spelling okr-10986-241312021-04-23T14:04:19Z Responding to Global Public Bads : Learning from Evaluation of the World Bank Experience with Avian Influenza 2006-13 Independent Evaluation Group INFLUENZA INFECTION STRAINS OF INFLUENZA DISEASE CONTAINMENT VETERINARY SERVICES HEALTH PLANNING LABORATORY FACILITIES VACCINATION AVIAN FLU PROTEIN COMMERCIAL POULTRY PRODUCTION VETERINARY AGENCIES SAMPLE COLLECTION ANTIVIRAL DEATH ANIMAL HEALTH ISSUES DISEASE SURVEILLANCE SYSTEMS VETERINARY AGENCY DISEASE REPORTING AVIAN INFLUENZA PROJECT HEALTH EMERGENCIES COMMUNICATION MATERIALS HOSPITAL ANIMAL HEALTH AVIAN INFLUENZA RESPONSE ACUTE RESPIRATORY SYNDROME HANDLING INFLUENZA SURVEILLANCE PREPAREDNESS ACTIVITIES PANDEMIC THREAT LABORATORY WASTE SECTORAL STRATEGY ZOONOTIC DISEASES ANIMAL HEALTH SURVEILLANCE DISEASE EMERGENCIES CHICKENS HUMAN INFLUENZA RESPONSE PLANS LABORATORIES DISEASE RISKS ANTIVIRAL DRUGS ANIMAL DEATH INFECTIOUS DISEASE EMERGENCIES BIRD FARMERS LIVE BIRD EPIDEMICS RESPIRATORY DISEASE BIRD POPULATIONS DISEASE OUTBREAKS OUTBREAKS OF AVIAN INFLUENZA PANDEMIC STRAIN PATHOGENIC AVIAN INFLUENZA HUMAN PANDEMIC DISASTER RISK MANAGEMENT AVIAN INFLUENZA INFECTION PANDEMIC RESPONSE WILD BIRDS AVIAN INFLUENZA OUTBREAKS CONFIRMED HUMAN CASES TRADE IN LIVESTOCK HPAI HOSTS PANDEMIC PREPAREDNESS EMERGING INFECTIOUS DISEASES ISOLATION WARDS SMALLHOLDER FARMERS LIVESTOCK SECTORS ANIMAL HEALTH SPECIALISTS WILD BIRD MIGRATION LIVESTOCK SPECIALISTS INFECTION IN HUMANS HEALTH SURVEILLANCE POULTRY DENSITY BURDEN OF DISEASE BORDER CONTROL ANIMAL HEALTH AGENCIES ANIMAL HEALTH COMPONENTS FOOD SAFETY RESPONSE CAPACITY DISEASE IN BIRDS ANIMAL DISEASE OUTBREAKS SITES FOR DISPOSAL FEED DISEASE RISK INDUSTRIAL POULTRY PRODUCTION DISINFECTANT LABORATORY M&E VACCINE HEALTH INTERVENTIONS RISK ASSESSMENTS HUMAN CASES OF AVIAN INFLUENZA BIOSECURITY ENVIRONMENTAL SAFEGUARDS POULTRY POULTRY VACCINATION DIAGNOSIS WILD BIRD POPULATIONS BIRDS DEATHS INFLUENZA PANDEMIC SICK BIRDS AGRICULTURE MINISTRY CULLED INFLUENZA EMERGENCY AVIAN INFLUENZA CONTROL HEMORRHAGIC FEVER POULTRY FARMS MONITORING AND EVALUATION OUTBREAKS INFLUENZA PLANS AVIAN INFLUENZA EMERGENCY AGRICULTURE ORGANIZATION DISEASED BIRDS PUBLIC HEALTH INFLUENZA PANDEMICS INFECTIOUS DISEASE STRAIN TYPES OF BIRDS EMERGENCY INTERVENTIONS INFLUENZA RESPONSE MOVEMENT OF BIRDS PANDEMIC SECTORAL STRATEGIES CONTAINMENT ANIMAL DISEASES RESPONSE PLANNING AIR TRAVEL POULTRY SECTOR INFECTIOUS DISEASES WORST CASE SCENARIOS LABORATORY EQUIPMENT LIVE BIRD MARKETS DIAGNOSTIC SYSTEMS MIGRATION ANIMAL DEATHS ANIMAL DISEASE BACKYARD FARMERS ZOONOTIC DISEASE PERSONAL PROTECTIVE EQUIPMENT LIVESTOCK PRODUCERS LIVESTOCK DISEASE SPREAD OUTBREAK EMERGENCY SUPPLIES REAGENTS COMMERCIAL FARMS POULTRY PRODUCTION DISEASE PREVENTION DIAGNOSTIC TESTS AVIAN INFLUENZA PROJECTS HUMAN INFECTIONS POULTRY SECTORS MUTATIONS FOOD SECURITY LIVESTOCK SECTOR BACKYARD POULTRY SYSTEMS INFLUENZA DOMESTIC POULTRY HUMAN HEALTH OUTCOMES PANDEMICS SURVEILLANCE INFECTION OF HUMANS DISEASE MANAGEMENT ANIMAL HEALTH SYSTEMS EMERGENCY RECOVERY VIROLOGY AVIAN INFLUENZA CRISIS SWINE BIRD MIGRATION WILD BIRD H5 The World Bank’s efforts to combat avian influenza and help countries to build capacity to prevent and mitigate pandemics offers a useful example in understanding how the agency can contribute to the provision of global public goods. This review aims to inform the provision of these goods by offering lessons from evaluation of the avian influenza experience. The experience also offers an example of the Bank playing a key role in the international response to an unfolding international crisis in a technical area with which it was largely unfamiliar. And provides a case study on how the Bank struggles to work effectively across sectors, both within the institution itself and in the client countries it operates in. The report aims to inform the design of any future avian influenza and zoonotic disease and pandemic preparedness interventions, and also to discuss the wider strategic lessons from the intervention that are relevant to programs responding to emergencies, providing global public goods, or cooperating with external technical agencies. The report also aims to assess the current state of the pandemic preparedness agenda, and to provide guidance on possible ways forward. The report also draws on additional interviews with Bank staff and international agency staff, on World Bank project and program documentation and reports, on the wider literature on avian influenza, and on other documents. 2016-04-25T19:53:05Z 2016-04-25T19:53:05Z 2013-01 Evaluation http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2016/04/26249213/responding-global-public-bads-learning-evaluation-world-bank-experience-avian-influenza-2006-13 http://hdl.handle.net/10986/24131 English en_US CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank World Bank, Washington, DC Publications & Research :: Working Paper Publications & Research