Comment on 'Counting the World's Poor' by Angus Deaton

Deaton s analysis of the problems with poverty counts and suggestions for improvement, including issues needing further research, are based on two distinct stages in counting the poor. At the first or international stage, a world poverty line is se...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author:	Srinivasan, T.N.
Format:	Journal Article
Language:	English en_US
Published:	Washington, DC: World Bank 2014
Subjects:	AGRICULTURAL LABORERS AGRICULTURAL WORKERS COMPETITIVE MARKETS CONSUMER EXPENDITURE CONSUMER PRICE INDEX CONSUMER PRICE INDEXES CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURE CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURES CONSUMPTION POVERTY CONVERSIONS CUMULATIVE DISTRIBUTION DETERMINANTS OF POVERTY DEVELOPING COUNTRIES DIMENSIONS OF POVERTY DURABLES ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ECONOMIC GROWTH ECONOMICS ESTIMATES OF POVERTY EXCHANGE RATE EXCHANGE RATES FOOD CONSUMPTION GLOBAL POVERTY GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT HEADCOUNT RATIO HOUSEHOLD CONSUMPTION HOUSEHOLD INCOME HOUSEHOLD SURVEYS HUMAN DEVELOPMENT HUMAN DEVELOPMENT INDEX HUMAN DEVELOPMENT REPORT HUMAN POVERTY HUMAN POVERTY INDEX INCIDENCE OF POVERTY INDICATORS OF POVERTY INFLATION INTERNATIONAL AGENCIES INTERNATIONAL BANK INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT INTERNATIONAL POVERTY LINE INTERNATIONAL TRADE LABOR MARKETS LEGAL SYSTEMS LOCAL CURRENCY LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MARKET PRICE MEAN EXPENDITURE NATIONAL ACCOUNTS NATIONAL POVERTY NATIONAL POVERTY LINE NATIONAL POVERTY LINES NUTRITION POLICY IMPLICATIONS POOR POOR COUNTRIES POOR HOUSEHOLDS POOR PEOPLE POPULOUS COUNTRIES POVERTY ALLEVIATION POVERTY ANALYSIS POVERTY ESTIMATES POVERTY INDICATOR POVERTY INDICATORS POVERTY LINE POVERTY LINES POVERTY MEASURE POVERTY OUTCOMES POVERTY REDUCTION PRICE CHANGE PRICE CHANGES PUBLIC SECTOR PURCHASING POWER REDUCTION IN POVERTY REDUCTION OF POVERTY REGIONAL POVERTY REGIONAL POVERTY LINES RETURN RURAL RURAL POOR RURAL POVERTY RURAL POVERTY LINE STOCKS TRANSACTION URBAN AREAS VALUATION
Online Access:	http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2001/09/17580166/comment-counting-worlds-poor-angus-deaton http://hdl.handle.net/10986/17132

id	okr-10986-17132
recordtype	oai_dc
spelling	okr-10986-171322021-04-23T14:03:29Z Comment on 'Counting the World's Poor' by Angus Deaton Srinivasan, T.N. AGRICULTURAL LABORERS AGRICULTURAL WORKERS COMPETITIVE MARKETS CONSUMER EXPENDITURE CONSUMER PRICE INDEX CONSUMER PRICE INDEXES CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURE CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURES CONSUMPTION POVERTY CONVERSIONS CUMULATIVE DISTRIBUTION DETERMINANTS OF POVERTY DEVELOPING COUNTRIES DIMENSIONS OF POVERTY DURABLES ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ECONOMIC GROWTH ECONOMICS ESTIMATES OF POVERTY EXCHANGE RATE EXCHANGE RATES FOOD CONSUMPTION GLOBAL POVERTY GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT HEADCOUNT RATIO HOUSEHOLD CONSUMPTION HOUSEHOLD INCOME HOUSEHOLD SURVEYS HUMAN DEVELOPMENT HUMAN DEVELOPMENT INDEX HUMAN DEVELOPMENT REPORT HUMAN POVERTY HUMAN POVERTY INDEX INCIDENCE OF POVERTY INDICATORS OF POVERTY INFLATION INTERNATIONAL AGENCIES INTERNATIONAL BANK INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT INTERNATIONAL POVERTY LINE INTERNATIONAL TRADE LABOR MARKETS LEGAL SYSTEMS LOCAL CURRENCY LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MARKET PRICE MEAN EXPENDITURE NATIONAL ACCOUNTS NATIONAL POVERTY NATIONAL POVERTY LINE NATIONAL POVERTY LINES NUTRITION POLICY IMPLICATIONS POOR POOR COUNTRIES POOR HOUSEHOLDS POOR PEOPLE POPULOUS COUNTRIES POVERTY ALLEVIATION POVERTY ANALYSIS POVERTY ESTIMATES POVERTY INDICATOR POVERTY INDICATORS POVERTY LINE POVERTY LINES POVERTY MEASURE POVERTY OUTCOMES POVERTY REDUCTION PRICE CHANGE PRICE CHANGES PUBLIC SECTOR PURCHASING POWER REDUCTION IN POVERTY REDUCTION OF POVERTY REGIONAL POVERTY REGIONAL POVERTY LINES RETURN RURAL RURAL POOR RURAL POVERTY RURAL POVERTY LINE STOCKS TRANSACTION URBAN AREAS VALUATION Deaton s analysis of the problems with poverty counts and suggestions for improvement, including issues needing further research, are based on two distinct stages in counting the poor. At the first or international stage, a world poverty line is set and used to derive comparable poverty lines for each country. At the second or domestic stage, the poverty lines are used to count the number of poor people in each country, and the others are added up over countries. He finds disquieting evidence about both stages of counting. The data for poverty counts in the second stage come from household surveys, whereas data on aggregate economic growth are from National Accounts Statistics (NAS). Deaton finds that in many countries there are large and growing disparities between survey data and national accounts so that there is no consistent empirical basis for conclusions about the extent to which growth reduces poverty. It is scandalous that even after nearly half a century of pursuing national and international programs for the eradication of mass poverty, the empirical foundations for assessing the success or failure of the programs and drawing lessons from them are so weak as to be deemed nonexistent. Abandoning them and focusing on national and subnational poverty analysis that goes beyond headcounts will be the sensible course to follow. The author focuses only on consumption-based poverty lines. The reason is the challenge of defining household income in a theoretically satisfactory manner and collecting data on income based on that definition through household surveys in any country (developed or developing). Deaton (1989) discusses the difficulties in meeting the challenge. Poverty counts based on income-based poverty lines are even more problematic than consumption-based ones. 2014-02-20T23:18:50Z 2014-02-20T23:18:50Z 2001-10 Journal Article http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2001/09/17580166/comment-counting-worlds-poor-angus-deaton World Bank Research Observer http://hdl.handle.net/10986/17132 English en_US CC BY-NC-ND 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/igo/ World Bank Washington, DC: World Bank Publications & Research :: Journal Article Publications & Research
repository_type	Digital Repository
institution_category	Foreign Institution
institution	Digital Repositories
building	World Bank Open Knowledge Repository
collection	World Bank
language	English en_US
topic	AGRICULTURAL LABORERS AGRICULTURAL WORKERS COMPETITIVE MARKETS CONSUMER EXPENDITURE CONSUMER PRICE INDEX CONSUMER PRICE INDEXES CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURE CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURES CONSUMPTION POVERTY CONVERSIONS CUMULATIVE DISTRIBUTION DETERMINANTS OF POVERTY DEVELOPING COUNTRIES DIMENSIONS OF POVERTY DURABLES ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ECONOMIC GROWTH ECONOMICS ESTIMATES OF POVERTY EXCHANGE RATE EXCHANGE RATES FOOD CONSUMPTION GLOBAL POVERTY GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT HEADCOUNT RATIO HOUSEHOLD CONSUMPTION HOUSEHOLD INCOME HOUSEHOLD SURVEYS HUMAN DEVELOPMENT HUMAN DEVELOPMENT INDEX HUMAN DEVELOPMENT REPORT HUMAN POVERTY HUMAN POVERTY INDEX INCIDENCE OF POVERTY INDICATORS OF POVERTY INFLATION INTERNATIONAL AGENCIES INTERNATIONAL BANK INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT INTERNATIONAL POVERTY LINE INTERNATIONAL TRADE LABOR MARKETS LEGAL SYSTEMS LOCAL CURRENCY LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MARKET PRICE MEAN EXPENDITURE NATIONAL ACCOUNTS NATIONAL POVERTY NATIONAL POVERTY LINE NATIONAL POVERTY LINES NUTRITION POLICY IMPLICATIONS POOR POOR COUNTRIES POOR HOUSEHOLDS POOR PEOPLE POPULOUS COUNTRIES POVERTY ALLEVIATION POVERTY ANALYSIS POVERTY ESTIMATES POVERTY INDICATOR POVERTY INDICATORS POVERTY LINE POVERTY LINES POVERTY MEASURE POVERTY OUTCOMES POVERTY REDUCTION PRICE CHANGE PRICE CHANGES PUBLIC SECTOR PURCHASING POWER REDUCTION IN POVERTY REDUCTION OF POVERTY REGIONAL POVERTY REGIONAL POVERTY LINES RETURN RURAL RURAL POOR RURAL POVERTY RURAL POVERTY LINE STOCKS TRANSACTION URBAN AREAS VALUATION
spellingShingle	AGRICULTURAL LABORERS AGRICULTURAL WORKERS COMPETITIVE MARKETS CONSUMER EXPENDITURE CONSUMER PRICE INDEX CONSUMER PRICE INDEXES CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURE CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURES CONSUMPTION POVERTY CONVERSIONS CUMULATIVE DISTRIBUTION DETERMINANTS OF POVERTY DEVELOPING COUNTRIES DIMENSIONS OF POVERTY DURABLES ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ECONOMIC GROWTH ECONOMICS ESTIMATES OF POVERTY EXCHANGE RATE EXCHANGE RATES FOOD CONSUMPTION GLOBAL POVERTY GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT HEADCOUNT RATIO HOUSEHOLD CONSUMPTION HOUSEHOLD INCOME HOUSEHOLD SURVEYS HUMAN DEVELOPMENT HUMAN DEVELOPMENT INDEX HUMAN DEVELOPMENT REPORT HUMAN POVERTY HUMAN POVERTY INDEX INCIDENCE OF POVERTY INDICATORS OF POVERTY INFLATION INTERNATIONAL AGENCIES INTERNATIONAL BANK INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT INTERNATIONAL POVERTY LINE INTERNATIONAL TRADE LABOR MARKETS LEGAL SYSTEMS LOCAL CURRENCY LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MARKET PRICE MEAN EXPENDITURE NATIONAL ACCOUNTS NATIONAL POVERTY NATIONAL POVERTY LINE NATIONAL POVERTY LINES NUTRITION POLICY IMPLICATIONS POOR POOR COUNTRIES POOR HOUSEHOLDS POOR PEOPLE POPULOUS COUNTRIES POVERTY ALLEVIATION POVERTY ANALYSIS POVERTY ESTIMATES POVERTY INDICATOR POVERTY INDICATORS POVERTY LINE POVERTY LINES POVERTY MEASURE POVERTY OUTCOMES POVERTY REDUCTION PRICE CHANGE PRICE CHANGES PUBLIC SECTOR PURCHASING POWER REDUCTION IN POVERTY REDUCTION OF POVERTY REGIONAL POVERTY REGIONAL POVERTY LINES RETURN RURAL RURAL POOR RURAL POVERTY RURAL POVERTY LINE STOCKS TRANSACTION URBAN AREAS VALUATION Srinivasan, T.N. Comment on 'Counting the World's Poor' by Angus Deaton
description	Deaton s analysis of the problems with poverty counts and suggestions for improvement, including issues needing further research, are based on two distinct stages in counting the poor. At the first or international stage, a world poverty line is set and used to derive comparable poverty lines for each country. At the second or domestic stage, the poverty lines are used to count the number of poor people in each country, and the others are added up over countries. He finds disquieting evidence about both stages of counting. The data for poverty counts in the second stage come from household surveys, whereas data on aggregate economic growth are from National Accounts Statistics (NAS). Deaton finds that in many countries there are large and growing disparities between survey data and national accounts so that there is no consistent empirical basis for conclusions about the extent to which growth reduces poverty. It is scandalous that even after nearly half a century of pursuing national and international programs for the eradication of mass poverty, the empirical foundations for assessing the success or failure of the programs and drawing lessons from them are so weak as to be deemed nonexistent. Abandoning them and focusing on national and subnational poverty analysis that goes beyond headcounts will be the sensible course to follow. The author focuses only on consumption-based poverty lines. The reason is the challenge of defining household income in a theoretically satisfactory manner and collecting data on income based on that definition through household surveys in any country (developed or developing). Deaton (1989) discusses the difficulties in meeting the challenge. Poverty counts based on income-based poverty lines are even more problematic than consumption-based ones.
format	Journal Article
author	Srinivasan, T.N.
author_facet	Srinivasan, T.N.
author_sort	Srinivasan, T.N.
title	Comment on 'Counting the World's Poor' by Angus Deaton
title_short	Comment on 'Counting the World's Poor' by Angus Deaton
title_full	Comment on 'Counting the World's Poor' by Angus Deaton
title_fullStr	Comment on 'Counting the World's Poor' by Angus Deaton
title_full_unstemmed	Comment on 'Counting the World's Poor' by Angus Deaton
title_sort	comment on 'counting the world's poor' by angus deaton
publisher	Washington, DC: World Bank
publishDate	2014
url	http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2001/09/17580166/comment-counting-worlds-poor-angus-deaton http://hdl.handle.net/10986/17132
_version_	1764433586549686272

Comment on 'Counting the World's Poor' by Angus Deaton

Similar Items