What Determines the Quality of Institutions?

In trying to explain institutional quality, different authors have come to conflicting conclusions. In tackling the problem themselves, the authors show three things. First, openness is positively and pretty robustly associated with institutional q...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Islam, Roumeen, Montenegro, Claudio E.
Format: Policy Research Working Paper
Language:English
en_US
Published: World Bank, Washington, DC 2013
Subjects:
GDP
GNP
Online Access:http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2002/01/1687157/determines-quality-institutions
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/15725
id okr-10986-15725
recordtype oai_dc
spelling okr-10986-157252021-04-23T14:03:19Z What Determines the Quality of Institutions? Islam, Roumeen Montenegro, Claudio E. TRADE LIBERALIZATION ETHNIC FACTORS QUALITY INSTITUTION BUILDING CROSS-COUNTRY EXPERIENCE NATURAL RESOURCES EXPORT CAPACITY INCOME LEVELS INCOME INEQUALITIES FREEDOM OF THE PRESS CHECKS & BALANCES ACCESS TO INFORMATION ACCOUNTABILITY AGGREGATING GOVERNANCE INDICATORS AMERICAN DEVELOPMENT BANK AMERICAN ECONOMIC REVIEW AVERAGE INCOME BUREAUCRACY BUREAUCRATIC QUALITY CHANGES IN GOVERNMENT CITIZENS CIVIL LAW COMMERCIAL CODE COMMON LAW COMPARATIVE DEVELOPMENT CORRUPTION COUNTRY COVERAGE COUNTRY RISK GUIDE DECENTRALIZATION DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ECONOMIC GROWTH ECONOMIC HISTORIANS ECONOMIC HISTORY ECONOMIC OUTCOMES ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE ECONOMIC REFORM ECONOMIC RESEARCH EXCHANGE OF IDEAS EXPORTS FINANCIAL DEVELOPMENT FORECASTING MODELS FREE PRESS GDP GDP PER CAPITA GINI COEFFICIENT GNP GNP PER CAPITA GOOD INSTITUTIONS GOOD POLICIES GOVERNANCE INDICATORS GOVERNMENT EFFECTIVENESS GRAFT GROWTH PERFORMANCE ICRG INCOME INCOME DISTRIBUTION INCOME INEQUALITY INEQUALITY INSTITUTION BUILDING INSTITUTIONAL CONSTRAINTS INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTIONAL ENVIRONMENT INSTITUTIONAL MEASURES INSTITUTIONAL QUALITY INTERNATIONAL COUNTRY RISK GUIDE INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT JUDICIAL INDEPENDENCE LEGAL ORIGIN LEGAL ORIGINS MEASUREMENT ERROR MEASURES PERCEPTIONS OF CORRUPTION NATURAL RESOURCES OPEN ECONOMIES POLICY MAKING POLICY MEASURES POLICY OUTCOMES POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL INSTABILITY POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS POLITICAL OUTCOMES POLITICAL SYSTEM PROPERTY RIGHTS PUBLIC GOODS QUALITY QUALITY INSTITUTIONS QUALITY OF GOVERNANCE QUALITY OF INSTITUTIONS REGULATORY BURDEN RENT SEEKING RULE OF LAW RULE OF LAW SELECTION BIAS SET OF GOVERNANCE INDICATORS SOCIAL INDICATORS STATE INSTITUTIONS TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE TRADE POLICY In trying to explain institutional quality, different authors have come to conflicting conclusions. In tackling the problem themselves, the authors show three things. First, openness is positively and pretty robustly associated with institutional quality. To minimize selection bias, the authors use data sets with the greatest cross-country coverage, though they also test the significance of the variables for smaller sample sizes. The results confirm that both natural and policy measures of openness are important. Concentration of trade in natural resource exports continues to be associated with poor institutional quality after openness in trade is accounted for. Second, "social" variables, such as income inequality or ethnic diversity, are not associated with institutional quality. The significance of the inequality variable disappears when continent dummy variables are included for Africa and Latin America. Third, features of specific institutions, such as freedom of the press and checks and balances in the political system, are positively associated with overall perceptions of institutional quality. These findings hold strongly across different data sets and samples even after the authors control for the variables commonly used in the literature. 2013-09-09T20:15:57Z 2013-09-09T20:15:57Z 2002-01 http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2002/01/1687157/determines-quality-institutions http://hdl.handle.net/10986/15725 English en_US Policy Research Working Paper;No. 2764 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank World Bank, Washington, DC Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper Publications & Research
repository_type Digital Repository
institution_category Foreign Institution
institution Digital Repositories
building World Bank Open Knowledge Repository
collection World Bank
language English
en_US
topic TRADE LIBERALIZATION
ETHNIC FACTORS
QUALITY
INSTITUTION BUILDING
CROSS-COUNTRY EXPERIENCE
NATURAL RESOURCES
EXPORT CAPACITY
INCOME LEVELS
INCOME INEQUALITIES
FREEDOM OF THE PRESS
CHECKS & BALANCES ACCESS TO INFORMATION
ACCOUNTABILITY
AGGREGATING GOVERNANCE INDICATORS
AMERICAN DEVELOPMENT BANK
AMERICAN ECONOMIC REVIEW
AVERAGE INCOME
BUREAUCRACY
BUREAUCRATIC QUALITY
CHANGES IN GOVERNMENT
CITIZENS
CIVIL LAW
COMMERCIAL CODE
COMMON LAW
COMPARATIVE DEVELOPMENT
CORRUPTION
COUNTRY COVERAGE
COUNTRY RISK GUIDE
DECENTRALIZATION
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMIC HISTORIANS
ECONOMIC HISTORY
ECONOMIC OUTCOMES
ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE
ECONOMIC REFORM
ECONOMIC RESEARCH
EXCHANGE OF IDEAS
EXPORTS
FINANCIAL DEVELOPMENT
FORECASTING MODELS
FREE PRESS
GDP
GDP PER CAPITA
GINI COEFFICIENT
GNP
GNP PER CAPITA
GOOD INSTITUTIONS
GOOD POLICIES
GOVERNANCE INDICATORS
GOVERNMENT EFFECTIVENESS
GRAFT
GROWTH PERFORMANCE
ICRG
INCOME
INCOME DISTRIBUTION
INCOME INEQUALITY
INEQUALITY
INSTITUTION BUILDING
INSTITUTIONAL CONSTRAINTS
INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT
INSTITUTIONAL ENVIRONMENT
INSTITUTIONAL MEASURES
INSTITUTIONAL QUALITY
INTERNATIONAL COUNTRY RISK GUIDE
INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT
JUDICIAL INDEPENDENCE
LEGAL ORIGIN
LEGAL ORIGINS
MEASUREMENT ERROR
MEASURES PERCEPTIONS OF CORRUPTION
NATURAL RESOURCES
OPEN ECONOMIES
POLICY MAKING
POLICY MEASURES
POLICY OUTCOMES
POLICY RESEARCH
POLITICAL INSTABILITY
POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS
POLITICAL OUTCOMES
POLITICAL SYSTEM
PROPERTY RIGHTS
PUBLIC GOODS
QUALITY
QUALITY INSTITUTIONS
QUALITY OF GOVERNANCE
QUALITY OF INSTITUTIONS
REGULATORY BURDEN
RENT SEEKING
RULE OF LAW
RULE OF LAW
SELECTION BIAS
SET OF GOVERNANCE INDICATORS
SOCIAL INDICATORS
STATE INSTITUTIONS
TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE
TRADE POLICY
spellingShingle TRADE LIBERALIZATION
ETHNIC FACTORS
QUALITY
INSTITUTION BUILDING
CROSS-COUNTRY EXPERIENCE
NATURAL RESOURCES
EXPORT CAPACITY
INCOME LEVELS
INCOME INEQUALITIES
FREEDOM OF THE PRESS
CHECKS & BALANCES ACCESS TO INFORMATION
ACCOUNTABILITY
AGGREGATING GOVERNANCE INDICATORS
AMERICAN DEVELOPMENT BANK
AMERICAN ECONOMIC REVIEW
AVERAGE INCOME
BUREAUCRACY
BUREAUCRATIC QUALITY
CHANGES IN GOVERNMENT
CITIZENS
CIVIL LAW
COMMERCIAL CODE
COMMON LAW
COMPARATIVE DEVELOPMENT
CORRUPTION
COUNTRY COVERAGE
COUNTRY RISK GUIDE
DECENTRALIZATION
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMIC HISTORIANS
ECONOMIC HISTORY
ECONOMIC OUTCOMES
ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE
ECONOMIC REFORM
ECONOMIC RESEARCH
EXCHANGE OF IDEAS
EXPORTS
FINANCIAL DEVELOPMENT
FORECASTING MODELS
FREE PRESS
GDP
GDP PER CAPITA
GINI COEFFICIENT
GNP
GNP PER CAPITA
GOOD INSTITUTIONS
GOOD POLICIES
GOVERNANCE INDICATORS
GOVERNMENT EFFECTIVENESS
GRAFT
GROWTH PERFORMANCE
ICRG
INCOME
INCOME DISTRIBUTION
INCOME INEQUALITY
INEQUALITY
INSTITUTION BUILDING
INSTITUTIONAL CONSTRAINTS
INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT
INSTITUTIONAL ENVIRONMENT
INSTITUTIONAL MEASURES
INSTITUTIONAL QUALITY
INTERNATIONAL COUNTRY RISK GUIDE
INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT
JUDICIAL INDEPENDENCE
LEGAL ORIGIN
LEGAL ORIGINS
MEASUREMENT ERROR
MEASURES PERCEPTIONS OF CORRUPTION
NATURAL RESOURCES
OPEN ECONOMIES
POLICY MAKING
POLICY MEASURES
POLICY OUTCOMES
POLICY RESEARCH
POLITICAL INSTABILITY
POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS
POLITICAL OUTCOMES
POLITICAL SYSTEM
PROPERTY RIGHTS
PUBLIC GOODS
QUALITY
QUALITY INSTITUTIONS
QUALITY OF GOVERNANCE
QUALITY OF INSTITUTIONS
REGULATORY BURDEN
RENT SEEKING
RULE OF LAW
RULE OF LAW
SELECTION BIAS
SET OF GOVERNANCE INDICATORS
SOCIAL INDICATORS
STATE INSTITUTIONS
TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE
TRADE POLICY
Islam, Roumeen
Montenegro, Claudio E.
What Determines the Quality of Institutions?
relation Policy Research Working Paper;No. 2764
description In trying to explain institutional quality, different authors have come to conflicting conclusions. In tackling the problem themselves, the authors show three things. First, openness is positively and pretty robustly associated with institutional quality. To minimize selection bias, the authors use data sets with the greatest cross-country coverage, though they also test the significance of the variables for smaller sample sizes. The results confirm that both natural and policy measures of openness are important. Concentration of trade in natural resource exports continues to be associated with poor institutional quality after openness in trade is accounted for. Second, "social" variables, such as income inequality or ethnic diversity, are not associated with institutional quality. The significance of the inequality variable disappears when continent dummy variables are included for Africa and Latin America. Third, features of specific institutions, such as freedom of the press and checks and balances in the political system, are positively associated with overall perceptions of institutional quality. These findings hold strongly across different data sets and samples even after the authors control for the variables commonly used in the literature.
format Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper
author Islam, Roumeen
Montenegro, Claudio E.
author_facet Islam, Roumeen
Montenegro, Claudio E.
author_sort Islam, Roumeen
title What Determines the Quality of Institutions?
title_short What Determines the Quality of Institutions?
title_full What Determines the Quality of Institutions?
title_fullStr What Determines the Quality of Institutions?
title_full_unstemmed What Determines the Quality of Institutions?
title_sort what determines the quality of institutions?
publisher World Bank, Washington, DC
publishDate 2013
url http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2002/01/1687157/determines-quality-institutions
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/15725
_version_ 1764429754110312448